Is this burning of devotees in Bangladesh sanctioned by Caitanya Mahaprabhu?
I thought Krishna Sanctions everything. Krishna also must have sanctioned Islam to exist just to kill his own devotees.
A lot of all religions lead to Krishna answer will not fly for this question. This was never true.
He sactioned the existance of other perverted religions, knowing full well they will kill his own devotees.
I have not found any reasonable answer to this.
We are all satisfied with the answers given here in this forum until an islamists comes kills you if you are a Man and Rapes the women in your house and Krishna dosen't show up. And the Founder of Islam sactioned this as Halal to rape Kafir Women. At that point you think maybe Krishna was just a convinient answer to explain away the crulty of this world.
Budhha had the best answer till now. This world is siffering and nothing you can do about it. If you are lucky you live long enough and not get killed that you have a tiny chance of Enlightenment.
Now if you put a God figure like Mahaprabhu who was in this land when cows were being slaughtered and I am pretty sure the ruler was killing hindus and destroying temples and raping women, even when caitanya mahaprabhu walked this land. But still he did nothing. With the story of Jagai and Madai they say Caitanya Mahaprabhu called his sudarshan Chakra, but is that really true? where is this sudarshan chakra now? His own appearance land of Bengal is being burned by islamists.
These are a number thoughts arising in my head.
I have no answer to give back.
Hare Krishna
You need to be a member of ISKCON Desire Tree | IDT to add comments!
Replies
Hare Krishna,
There is no hindu and muslim.
There is good and bad people.
We need to catch hold of the bad people who are going against the rules and regulations laid by Krishna and take an action.
Sudharshan Chakra will come when all good people join hands be it hindu or muslim or christians and fight leaving behind their religious sentiments.
If that is not possible then only a sect of hindus fighting for hindus is as much equal to a muslim sect claiming its religion superior and condemning other relgions.
All good people must leave all religion and dharma aside and come under one religion that is Krishna religion and Practice and preach only OnE book Bhagwad gita.
BTW.. Bhagwad gita is far above all religions and it is a manual to How To Live. So, don't attach BG to be only to Hindu religon.
ANYONE WHO HAS A KIND HEART WHO CAN UNDERSTAND THE SUFFERING OF OTHER JEEVA MUST FOLLOW ONLY ONE TEXT BOOK THAT IS BHAGWAD GITA AND MUST BECOME DEVOTEE OF KRISHNA
IF ALL GOOD PEOPLE IN THIS WORLD BECOME FOLLOW ONLY KRISHNISM and LEAVE ALL OTHER RELIGIONS LIKE HINDUSIM, SIKHISM, ISLAM, JAISIM, CHIRISTIANITY etc etc. whatever are existing. THEN WE ALL CAN WIPE OUT THE BAD ( DEMON). IS IT POSSIBLE?
Hare Krishna prabhuji
we tend to forget that krishna is not our goods supplier, just because we want him to come down and save us he won't come down to shoot his disc here and there.
kālo ’smi loka-kṣaya-kṛt pravṛddho
lokān samāhartum iha pravṛttaḥ
ṛte ’pi tvāṁ na bhaviṣyanti sarve
ye ’vasthitāḥ praty-anīkeṣu yodhāḥ
The Supreme Personality of Godhead said: Time I am, the great destroyer of the worlds, and I have come here to destroy all people. With the exception of you [the Pāṇḍavas], all the soldiers here on both sides will be slain. (BG 11.32)
ultimately whoever is being killed , whatever is being eradicated - is all sanctioned by Krishna. Of course
We also cannot forget about how what happens with us is actually based on our own last karmas.
Raghu das ji was a great devotee of lord Jagannath but he also suffered a very servere health condition, lord told him that it is his last prarabdh left after that he will come to lord in his abode.
also whatever is in this world in material thus temporary nothing is permanent. People WILL be killed , places WILL be destroyed. This is the effect of kaliyuga.
Is this burning of devotees in Bangladesh sanctioned by Caitanya Mahaprabhu? - sanatana Goswami was in a Jail before he ran away to go to mahaprabhu. That was done by mahaprabhu? Exactly!
Can we understand why he DID that ? NO - absolutely not, we cannot comprehend what an ultimately smart being (God) will do and why.
I thought Krishna Sanctions everything. Krishna also must have sanctioned Islam to exist just to kill his own devotees.- other pseudo religions exist because we deviated from sanatana Dharma from varnashram dharm.
people who are doing wrong are doing there karma and they will be punished but it is not a blinkit order that you will get in 10 minutes.
Srila Prabhupada suffered a lot during his life , do u think Krishna also watched it with no care? If yes then why would srila Prabhupada still go for preaching for God realisation for krsna consciousness? Because he could understand what are atrocities, that as long as we have this material body there will be sufferings that's why we are endeavouring to get out of this.
Budhha had the best answer till now. - lord Buddha was none other than Krishna. And yes he had the right answer "non violence" , which Krishna tells us to follow in bhagavad gita BUT he also tells Arjun that you shall fight as they (kurus) have caused perils for his devotees (Pandavas) and thus shall be slain. And Krsna tells Arjun that he has to resort to violence if it comes to protect themselves.
If you are talking about some other answer please mention in your reply.
Now if you put a God figure like Mahaprabhu who was in this land when cows were being slaughtered and I am pretty sure the ruler was killing hindus and destroying temples and raping women, even when caitanya mahaprabhu walked this land. But still he did nothing - first of all mahaprabhu convinced Muslims of navdip to stop killing cows and to allow Hari nama sankirtan. And even if we forget that, let's see what mahaprabhu gave us :-
harer nāma harer nāma
harer nāmaiva kevalam
kalau nāsty eva nāsty eva
nāsty eva gatir anyathā
In this age of quarrel and hypocrisy, the only means of deliverance is the chanting of the holy names of the Lord. There is no other way. There is no other way. There is no other way (CC madhya 6.242)
the answer is simple we have been given this "Hare krsna hare krsna krsna krsna hare hare , hare Rama hare Rama Rama Rama hare hare" to save ourselves. Krishna IS with us, there is no difference between he himself and his name.
While draupadi was being disrobed Krishna was not personally present there just his name which was spoken by Krishna supplied cloth to her. Of course we are not a very exalted devotee like draupadi, but KRISHNA will protect us.
if Krishna can maintain a black ant on a black rock in a black well on a black night, then why won't be maintain me?
Especially when I am chanting his name , serving him. We just need faith which we lack right now .
"His own appearance land of Bengal is being burned by islamists."- the land of appearance which we see is material place being burned , of course it is same navdip as in the spiritual world, but the one being burned is not that spiritual place.
If you have any arguments against it, then I am all ears.
Hare Krishna