Replies

                    • Sevak

                      Hare Krsna 

                      Concept of omnipotence and free will are contradicting each other.

                      They are not. Let us take example for illustration. A mother gives offers a choice between ice cream and 500 Rupee note to her 2.5 year old child. The mother who knows everything about her child since birth can easily know what her child will pick. Is the mother forcing her child to make the choice of picking ice cream ?  - NO

                      So it is possible to know what choices a person picks without interfering in the person's free will. This is not a rare phenomenon. It happens all around us. From the way food vendors sell samosa in trains to selection of location for malls. Large tech companies are investing in profiling of common people in order to know every possible detail about every person. Their intention is to control the people by knowing about them. 

                      But Sri Krsna is not like that. Krsna doesn't even need to blink to anything about anyone. He knows everything about everyone. Yet he chooses not to interfere in free will of the living entity. This is confirmed by Sri Krsna in Bhagavad Gita 

                      ye yathā māṁ prapadyante
                      tāṁs tathaiva bhajāmy aham

                      As all surrender unto Me, I reward them accordingly. ( BG 4.11)

                      In the above shloka Sri Krsna says that He reciprocates with the desires of living entity as they approach Him. Hiranyakasipu saw Krsna as enemy and wanted to destroy the lord. So Krsna fought him as Narasimha and killed him, Prahlad saw Krsna as his worshippable master and Lord Narasimha reciprocated by protecting and providing him. 

                      samo ’haṁ sarva-bhūteṣu
                      na me dveṣyo ’sti na priyaḥ

                      I envy no one, nor am I partial to anyone. I am equal to all. ( BG 9.29)

                      Here again Sri Krsna says that he is impartial. Krsna gave choice to both Duryodhana and Arjuna before battle of Kurukshetra if they wanted to have Krsna without weapon on their side or Krsna's army. Arjuna picked Sri Krsna (as would have any of his brothers). If Duryodhana was given the first choice  obviously he would have chosen the army.

                      So Krsna is impartial in giving choices and He knows the what each and every living entity will choose without any uncertainity in the past present and future. But He still does not interfere in the free will of living entity and is very detatched and uncontrolling.

                      If someone is still not convinced then they may understand that it is the power of god to know everything and still not control others. If it is still contradictory, Then Krsna is personification of contradictions. 

                      Hare Krsna

                    • "They know the future" is a very broad statement, whether it's God or rishis. Anyway thanks for trying to explain.

                       

                    • E-Counselor

                      The best way to understand is by realisation. The best way to realise is chanting attentively. I know you are thinking I have gone mad of run out of answers, thats why I am saying the "oen size fits all" statement.

                      Its not like that. 

                      Not only God, there are so many trikaalagya rishis in our history, maybe now also. They also know the future. Does that mean they try to change the future ? 

                      To a certain extent, we also know the future - child who is newborn will be 5 yrs old in so many years. Will fall ill, have usual growing up pangs like any other new born to 5 yr old. So most of it is general. Specific is where we have to understand.

                      Lord is specific. He knows, does not mean we know. We have to undergo our journey of learning and unlearning and doing what is destined and growing spiritually out of it.

                      Haribol,

                      Your servant,

                      Radha Rasamayi DD

                    • It's not a question of omnipotence that we know, it's question of knowing everything i.e. knowing the future (which implies he knows what our actions will be in future), that is why we say he is omniscient. So this is what is confusing, i.e. we are told Lord knows what we will do in future, but then tell us we have free will, both concepts are contradicting each other.

  • There is no any external god. God is within u. But it is overlapped by ur mind, emotions and thoughts. There are three qualities within u as rajas, tamas and satwa. Based on dominance of the quality everyone do karma. These qualities are in subconscious mind and all Spritual act is to make it concious.. 

    • Sevak

      Hare Krsna 

      God is within u. But it is overlapped by ur mind, emotions and thoughts.

      If by the above statement you mean that God is overlapped by mind etc the above statement is very inaccurate. Sri Krsna is certainly situated within everyone's heart as stated by Sri Krsna Himself in Bhagavad Gita. But Sri Krsna is/can never be covered by anything material like mind etc. Sri Krsna is always free and independent. The living entity or jiva is covered by mind etc. And most importantly jiva/ living entity and paramatma/ Krsna are two different entities. Jiva can never become Krsna even after achieving highest perfection by any processes for the rest of eternity and beyond time/space. 

      There is no any external god.

      This statement is also quite inaccurate. God is both external and internal. God is omnipresent everywhere. Best example is of Lord  Narasimha deva. Prahlad maharaj saw Krsna everywhere within and without. His father couldn't see Krsna anywhere. Hiranyakashipu had infact declared himself as god for all practical purposes much like most bogus mayavadis. But just like most bogus mayavadis who equate jiva with god, Hiranyakashipu was wrong. Sri Krsna appeared from pillar, proving His omnipresence and destroyed the false god - Hiranyakashipu. 

      Hare Krsna

    • Thank you pr g

       

  • Hare Krishna Prabhu ji, 

    Lord loves everyone equally and want everyone to get corrected and come back to home but he never interferes the act of jivas . The reasons are ---

    1. free will of jivas, lord has given certain amount free will to jivas by which thy can make choices of their actions.

    2. Lord wants evry jiva to get understand the difference between right and wrong. If thy don't allowed to wait for watching drastic reactions coming out of their actions they would never understand the urgency to correct their actions and conciousness.

    3. Lord stops jivas to do sin but he has his own way of perception which is inconceivable like while durvasa muni came to pandavas for feast during exile lord come to solve their puzzle so that thy can be saved from the sin against saints. So lord comes evrytime but he pefroms in his own way . He reciprocates to the persons as per the level of their devotion.

    4. There is one reason could also be seen. Many things are already described in our scripturres like the time period of material universes. Their schedule, the time of pralay , the time of sarg, the time of mahapralay and mahasarg and all. If lord comes and stops every wrong thing going as per our perception then these prescribed schedule or drama of material world will get over before schedule. Which is like falseship of scripture that can not be happened.

    5. Even in spiritual planets some Lila's happened between lord's devotees as we can see in case of doorkeepers of vaikuntha . Curse was given by sanakadi to them to take birth as demons. So thy had to be demon and incur sins and lord can't stop them in mid before ryt comes.  

    Over all the point comes out is this only that whatever happens in lords  screation is literally inconceivable by us.  Every situation and happening or mishappenings there are past histories. Lord knows everything and does everything at ryt time in ryt manner. What we are supposed to do is just to surrender supreme personality of Godhead in every circumstance.

    If I am wrong anywhere pls forgive me.

    Thnx

    Hare Krishna

    • Prabhu ji,

      I think Hemant is asking why Lord not stop sinner from making sin, yes there is free will but say a sinner go and kill a person, why Lord not stop him? because the person now killed and he was innocent victim, why Lord not save him from being killed. But if you say he was killed because of past Karma, then that means killer has not committed sin because the man deserved to die because of past Karma, therefore question now is when is sin a sin ?

      • Hare Krishna Prabhu ji,

        Whatever happens happens for many reasons and it is inconceivable, for example gangaputra bhishma took birth in mritulok while he was Vasu originally but due to curse he has to live in mritulok, now what action he needs to act is his choice it is not the impact of his curse like he kidnapped amba but dint accept amba, then amba also has choice to react this and she chose to be reason to kill bhishma which reflected in her next life. So whatever happens doesn't necessarily happens to be past life reaction. Some new karma based out of choices also created that leads to further lives. And the right to do new karma along with dealing with past life reactions is available in human life only. One can chose to react past life reactions as per the perspective of devotional path and one can chose to do new act devotionally. Becuz devotional acts can burn the bondage of karmas.

        Thanks,

        Hare Krishna

This reply was deleted.