Is Allah,yahweh and other fake or are they demigods under lord Krishna?

In Hinduism there are many sects like shaivism and Vaishnavism

Each claiming theirs god are supreme,are the other religions like that saying their gods are real?

You need to be a member of ISKCON Desire Tree | IDT to add comments!

Join ISKCON Desire Tree | IDT

Email me when people reply –

Replies

      • Sevak

        Hare Krsna 

        It is not correct to consider Sanatana Dharma as the only religion. Sanatana Dharma is the highest religion. Within Sanatana Dharma there are many paths. Bhakti is not the only path. Bhakti is the highest path.

        Srila Prabhupada himself said Jesus Christ was sent by Krsna. So considering Jesus Christ or other bona fide representatives as bogus and paths given by them as bogus against the teachings of our own acarya is very similar offence arising due to an egoistic self righteous attitude of 'My way is the only way'. 

        This attitude of 'My way is the only way' is a very major flaw in the non-vedic religions which manifests as much violence. To accept the same atttitude by followers of Sanatana Dharma is not correct. It is the glory of Sanatana Dharma that it talks of other religion. It is all encompassing and inclusive of bona fide religions. At the same time it also strictly and strongly warns of the deficiencies of other religions and philosophies such as mayavada etc. Sanata Dharma is very beautiful. It is to be experienced by strictly following the acaryas. 

        I wud like to know what comes under this extremely sinful category

        I do not know all the details of this. But Islam has warnings for its followers prohibiting sexual relations with one's mother and sister. The necessity of such clear warnings indicates that the people to whom Islam was given indulged in such animalistic activities before Islam. So the target audience of Islam was extremely degraded people. Hence what Prophet Muhammad gave was something to elevate them from that condition. Prophet muhammad was compassionate on those living beings to give them god. He didn't have time or the means to preach details accurately. Some say his life was endangered because of giving Islam similar to Jesus christ. 

        How to see other religions ?

        See the positives. The compassion of the originators like Jesus Christ etc. There are many strict followers who are very disciplined in following their religion. Many of the followers have high degree of loyalty to their practices. 

        This should inspire us to be grateful to our gurus and acaryas and inspire us to follow our path of bhakti with enthisuasm. 

        YS Bharat

    • No no no prabhu usually ur answers are very good but for once u are erring. It is not that rape loot murder committed by indians are least sinful and those by Arabs are extremely sinful. Sins have got nothing to do with different areas of earth. This whole earth was ruled by a king of ur good name. That time there was only one religion one language even up till the end of dvapar yuga. And extremely sinful were demons like hiranyaksha aghasura bakasura. They were horrific man eaters and tormented all but they knew that they could not become powerful unless they obtained a benediction from lord bramha which means sanathan dharma. They did not manufacture their own religion. So suddenly what extreme sins occurred that god had to send mahamad?? Ever since kali began every nook and corner of earth was afflicted by sinful ppl and god does promote animal sacrifice like ashwamedha yadnya but ithe is banned in kaliyug due to absence of qualified brahinsa and maleccha word is used only for mahamad read bhavishya puran and mahamad has done several abominable sins which is confirmed even by their own famous Egyptian scholar of medieval times named al-suyuti. How can such a sinful person represent god?
      • Sevak

        Hare Krsna 

        I do think there is any error in what was mentioned by me. This is what Srila Prabhupad has said. There is vast difference in understanding of what others here have of other religions and what Sila Prabhupad gave understanding of other religions. In fact even Srila Bhakti vindo thakur has mentioned about other religions like Christianity, Islam etc. 

        It doesn't matter what the people are following, what matters is what the holy books and original teachings of originator of the religion has recommended. This is not a comparison between religions, that is not correct. It is whether it is genuine or not. That has to be looked at objectively, not looking at the current practices. 

        For this purpose one can see this book in detail. 

        http://ebooks.iskcondesiretree.com/pdf/Comparitive_Religion/The_Ved...

        YS Bharat

        • Sevak

          Hare Krsna 

          First sentence should have been - I don't think there is any error in what was mentioned by me.

          YS Bharat

    • Sevak

      Hare Krsna 

      God doesn't promote animal slaughter. 

      As per Islam animal salughter is not promoted. It is allowed in a restricted sense. 

      We have to understand that Islam was taught to people who were extremely sinful. They would have done it anyway. If they were given a religion which completely forbids animal slaughtering, they would have rejected the religion and continued their sinful activities godlessly. 

      Don't mistake me I am not saying animal slaughtering is justified. It is sinful. But the point is how do u give understanding of god to people addicted to animal slaughter ?

      So what Islam aims at is to restrict sinful activities at same time give them some understanding of a superior entity called god. 

      There are specific rules about animal slaughter in Islam it must be divided into 7 portions, 6 should be given to others and only one is to be used. These rules are there to restrict the practice with the aim to eliminate it. Not to promote it. 

      We have to understand how the religion originated, for what audience it was taught and what is the effect it had on them. The modern practices are not as per the rules of Islam. 

      mleccha etc is used for the audience to whom religion was taught. Because of their addiction to sinful activities.

      YS Bharat

      • Ignorance and innocence of any one is very dangerous to him/her & others.Some staunch followers of some religion ask these questions-1-How come cow is god for you or sacred? It is an animal simply made by our god to cut and eat. 2- How come Dropdai had 4 husbands? 3- How come Ganesh god has elephant head? How is possible? 4- How come Hanuman God is monkey where as monkeys can neither talk and fly.  How come he flew and swallowed the sun when he was child? You do not have answers?So get converted to our religion of peace. For these questions answers are with this man- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k7-oEqtIDw8     . This man asks counter questions unanswerable by their followers like their so called prophet went to meet their god on a horse which had wings. How the hell a horse will have wings? Ok. Where did he park that horse having wings in sky? Like their god cut the moon into 2 pieces by sword. 

        If really anyone wants to get light on truth, he/she must read " Satyarth Prakash" book by Swami Dayanand. Blindly coming to conclusion is very dangerous. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZyesfU-T-wI

  • Sri Haridasa Namacarya said :
    "All living entities in creation are inspired by the Lord in the heart to act in different ways. People of different religions praise the Lord's holy names and qualities according to the view of their scriptures. The Supreme Lord accepts everyone's mood. If anyone shows malice towards another's religion he ac­tually shows malice to the Lord Himself, who is worshiped by that religion. Since God is one, that person becomes envious of the same Supreme Lord that he himself is worshiping."

    .

    When one is envious on Lord, all the effort in a spiritual life is like putting the water in a broken pot. 

    • To understand religions we need to know the time,place and circumstances they were preached at,we should also know the life of the Prophets and not judge by the external institutions that grew out of it.

      For instance to understand Islam one needs to know Muhammad how he lived,where he lived and what kind of people he preached to, then one will understand why he did some things that he did and are now current viewed as immoral but at that time at that circumstance that was the perfect decision.

      Life of Prophet Muhammad (BBC,Subtibles)

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wwrBQzhoS6k

      Srila Prabhupada on Islam;

      "Chaitanya Mahaprabhu proved devotional Service from the Qur'an.
      So it requires a devotee who can explain God from any godly literature."

      Srila Prabhupada


      In depth study on Islam from Prabhupadas statements and shastric quotations:
      http://www.harekrsna.de/artikel/islam.htm

      After we study the above mentioned sources  we can understand Islam as it is.

      • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6gcP57BDTac. If anyone wants to understand very well the religion of peace he/she must see this video. And also of Tarek Fateh, Taslima Nasreen and Salman Rushdie. https://www.thereligionofpeace.com/ . Coming to conclusion blindly is very dangerous. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k7-oEqtIDw8

      • And one more thing the harekrsna.de site has 108 names of lord shiva and at the end it is written that these names destroy all sins. On this issue devotees have gone bang bang at shaivites several times. Plz look into the matter.thanks 

        Hare Krishna Tempel Portal - Das Tor zur spirituellen Welt
        Informationsportal zur Philosophie und den Lehren der Hare Krishna Bewegung - ISKCON - International Society for Krishna Consciousness, gegründet von…
This reply was deleted.