A humble inquiry to the devotees

All glories to Śrīla Prabhupāda!

Hare Kṛṣṇa, dear devotees. 🙏

I have a humble question regarding the narrations of Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam, and I would be very grateful if the senior devotees could kindly help me understand this point.

As we know, Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam was first spoken by Śrīla Śukadeva Gosvāmī to Mahārāja Parīkṣit approximately 5,000 years ago, on the banks of the Ganges at a place traditionally identified as Śukratal, near present-day Delhi. Many great sages assembled there, and Śrīla Sūta Gosvāmī was also present in that assembly.

Later, we find that Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam was narrated by Śrīla Sūta Gosvāmī to the assembled sages at Naimiṣāraṇya, headed by Śaunaka Ṛṣi. The narration mentions an assembly of many sages, traditionally described as 88,000 ṛṣis.

My humble understanding is that Sūta Gosvāmī was present during the narration by Śukadeva Gosvāmī to Mahārāja Parīkṣit, and he later narrated the same Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam to the sages at Naimiṣāraṇya.

My humble question is:

If the narration at Naimiṣāraṇya took place approximately 2,500 years after the time of Mahārāja Parīkṣit, how was Śrīla Sūta Gosvāmī present in both assemblies?

Am I misunderstanding the chronology, or is there a particular explanation given in Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam or in the purports of Śrīla Prabhupāda regarding the lifespan and presence of Śrīla Sūta Gosvāmī in these two events?

I sincerely request all the senior and learned devotees to kindly enlighten me on this point. I am asking purely from a desire to understand the beautiful narrations of Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam more deeply.

Thank you all for your valuable guidance.

Hare Kṛṣṇa! 🙏

All glories to Śrīla Prabhupāda!

You need to be a member of ISKCON Desire Tree | IDT to add comments!

Join ISKCON Desire Tree | IDT

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Thank you for asking this question dear @Tanmayee Goswami prabhu ji,

    Hare Krishna,

    You know what this question indeed made me realize something. 

    Balarama severed the head of Romaharshan:- Romaharshana is the disciple of Vyas dev ji.

    Unfortunately, after being worshiped and seated at His place, Lord Balarama saw Romaharsana, the disciple of Vyasadeva (the literary incarnation of Godhead), still sitting on the vyasasana. He had neither gotten up from his seat nor offered Him respects. Because he was seated on the vyasasana, he foolishly thought himself greater than the Lord; therefore he did not get down from the seat or bow down before the Lord. Lord Balarama then considered the history of Romaharsana: he was born in a suta family, or a mixed family, born of a brahmana woman and a ksatriya man. Therefore although Romaharsana considered Balarama a ksatriya, he should not have remained sitting on a higher seat.

    When Balarama went to Piligrimage during Mahabharata yudha .. this all happened. 

    Then, after consulting with other sages Balarama ji made him alive again by taking a part of body of Romaharshana and make it alive so SUTA born from the body of the Romahasharana is techinically not the son but he is son ( like from the body Romaharshana came out or re-liven ).

    The Supreme Personality of Godhead therefore solved the problem in a manner befitting His exalted position, and said, "Because the son is produced from the body of the father, it is the injunction of the Vedas that the son is the father's representative. Therefore I say that Ugrasrava Suta, the son of Romaharsana Suta, should henceforth take his father's position and continue the discourses on the Puranas, and because you wanted Romaharsana to have a long duration of life, this benediction will be transferred to his son. The son, Ugrasrava, will therefore have all the facilities you offered--long duration of life in a good and healthy body, without any disturbances and full strength of all the senses."

    So, Suta ji is techinically disciple of Vyas ji.

    https://harekrsna.com/philosophy/associates/demons/balarama/romahar...

    This is was being performed initially by Romaharshana and continued by Suta ji who is none other than the same person.

    Then, this yagna is performed during Mahabharata as we come to know that this all incident happened when Balarama didn't participate in Mahabharata and went on a piligrimage.

    So, this was previously being told and continued there after.

    romaharsana.gif

    Balarama Kills Romaharsana Suta
    With a Blade of Grass

     

    NOW  the question comes where from this 2500 years ago came.

    I am seeing a thirtha called Chakra Thirtha it is a place where exactly this incident took place.

    OIP.kYdE18A9ig78izQpREP4pgHaD4?r=0&pid=Api&h=220&P=0

    Did you visit this place. I wish I can do. This is in Naimisharanya.  The place where 88,000 sages performed the Yagna for 12 years. It is said there as per Sthala Purana.

     

     

  • Hare Krsna

    From where did you get the misinformation that the narration at Naimisaranya took place 2,500 years after the time of Maharaja Pariksit?

    "Srimad-Bhagavatam was composed just prior to the beginning of the age of Kali (about five thousand years ago), and Lord Buddha appeared about twenty-six hundred years ago. Therefore in the Srimad-Bhagavatam Lord Buddha is foretold. Such is the authority of this clear scripture."

    Srimad-Bhagavatam 1.3.24 PURPORT

    If indeed the Srimad-Bhagavatam was narrated by Srila Suta Gosvami 2,500 years after it's narration to Maharaja Pariksit then the incarnation of Lord Buddha would have already taken place by then so there was no need to mention that the activities of Lord Buddha were foretold.

    Hari bol

    • Dandawat Pranam Prabhu ji. Can you explain the chronology in short . somewho it is in my mind that the Srimad Bhagavatam that we are reading is somewhat 2500 years old ,though it was told by Sukhadev goswami approx 5000 years back to Parakshit Maharaj.

      • Hare Krsna

        You have got the chronology right. Nothing wrong with that. 

        Suta Gosvami heard the Bhagavatam from Sukadeva Gosvami and after Sukadeva Gosvami left and the departure of Maharaja Pariksit, the sages at Naimisaranya held a 1,000 year sacrifice at which Suta Gosvami was elected as speaker by the sages headed by Saunaka rsi. 

        All of this happened approximately 5,000 years ago. The sages started the sacrifice to counter the ill effects of the age of Kali which had just begun. 

        We cannot confirm the exact date since it is not mentioned but my request to you is to stop making assumptions where it is not required.

        If you are truly humble then you would have accepted the authoritative quote from the PURPORT to Srimad-Bhagavatam 1.3.24 that i provided to you earlier instead of relying on your mind because it still seems you are not convinced that it happened more than 2,500 years ago.

        There is no ' it maybe like this ' or ' perhaps it was like that ' or ' how it somehow comes to your mind.'

        Hari bol

         

        • Dandawat Pranam 

          Prabhu Ji

          Hare Krishna

  • Sevak

    Hare Krsna 

    Narration of Srimad Bhagavatam by Suta Gosvami did not happen 2,500 years after the time of Mahārāja Parīkṣit. 

    Hare Krsna

  • Hare Krishna,

    People of Satyuga lived for many many years. Like their life spans were extending for 10,000 yrs. This you can see from this perticular SB sloka

    ŚB 1.1.4

    naimiṣe ’nimiṣa-kṣetre
    ṛṣayaḥ śaunakādayaḥ
    satraṁ svargāya lokāya
    sahasra-samam āsata

    Once, in a holy place in the forest of Naimiṣāraṇya, great sages headed by the sage Śaunaka assembled to perform a great thousand-year sacrifice for the satisfaction of the Lord and His devotees.

    Purport

    Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam, after its first recitation by Śrīla Śukadeva Gosvāmī, was repeated for the second time at Naimiṣāraṇya.

     

    ----Logically speaking can anyone survive a thousand years as per our modern calcualtions of life span. Then how was this yajna performed for Thousand- years?

     

    People of Satyuga had a lifespan of 100,000 years and people of treta yuga had a life span of 10,000 yrs and people during Dwapar yuga lived for about 1000  years.  Could be Suta Goswami ji belonged to Dwapar yuga and when he listened to the story from Sri Shuka's mouth he was many be an young boy in his 20 yrs or 30yrs.. maybe he lived later for another say 2000 -3000 years? Now this is not known.. we cannot speculate.

    But the known fact is that the ( SB 1.1.4) which says the yagna at Naimisharyana headed by Suta goswami and attended by Saunak aadi rishi lasted for 1000 years. Where Suta Goswami ji spoke about whatever he listened previously from Shree Shukadev goswami. One don't know was Suta living the entire time tilll the end of the Thousand years until the yujna was over?? or he gave the 7 day lecture and left for Vaikuntha? 

    how can anyone do a 1000-year sacrifice? Is this even possible? If possible where these sages already attained Bhagwad dhaam and coming back to just to perform the yagna there?

    Possible.. Because ONE who directly listen Srimad Bhagwatam from the lotus lips of Sri Shukadev ji would have gone back to godhead. Why would they even continue on the earth?

    maybe the sage Suta Goswami ji after attaining Bhagwad dhaam came back just to pass the information to other sages out of compaassion to spread the Knowledge to others.

    Hare Krishna

This reply was deleted.