Hare krishna all devotees..dandwat pranam, 

I had some doubts.

If anyone has commited 1st offence to the holy name 'sadhu ninda' or a 'vaishnava apradh'.

Will his chanting have negative impact on him and his life..is offensive chanting very dangerous?

I read somewhere but i dont remember that,Srila Bhakti vinod Thakur ji writes...that "when someone commits vaishnava apradh, if he chants more and more he gets sukriti and that sukriti gives him devotee association"...please i cant find exactly where i read that..please tell me where is it written, and please answer my queries.


Thank you

Dandwat pranam

Hare krishna

You need to be a member of ISKCON Desire Tree | IDT to add comments!

Join ISKCON Desire Tree | IDT

Email me when people reply –


  • E-Counselor
    Hare Krsna Prabhuji,
    I heard in a lecture in Mayapur (don't recall name of speaker), that of the 10 offences, no 1 and no 7 are the most dangerous to commit. The only atonement for Sady Ninda is to fall at the lotus feet of that devotee whom we criticized and beg his forgiveness. It is possible that he may not forgive, then we take the dust of lotus feet of that devotee pn our heads.
    While we all want to stay away from aparadh, it is inevitable, atleast in the beginning of our KC journey.
    So we should continue to chant, whether offensively or offenselessly or anything in between. With determination, please complete your rounds for the day, every day.
    Your servant,
    Radha Rasamayi DD
This reply was deleted.