hare krishna prabhu ji,i have very much doubt about god.i am sometimes worship but since my heart does not allow to worship like chanting ,reading gita,bhagawatam.when i am watching serial,and about other religion .then due to these book have not scientific prove.i am very upset.argument of these book is looking like similar in real life.i have lot of doubt .some iskcon prabhu ji are not giving appropriate answer so please help me.
You need to be a member of ISKCON Desire Tree | IDT to add comments!
Those who are puffed up with material education, wealth, aristocracy and fruitive activity are very proud of possessing material things, and they often deride the true devotees. Even if such people offer the Lord worship, the Lord never accepts them.
Devotees who do not have material possessions, but are happy only with possessing devotional service, consider to be dear to Lord.
By showing mercy to all living entities and restricting the senses from sense enjoyment, one can very quickly satisfy the Lord. And when Lord is satisfied, what can not be achieved.
Hare Krishna prabhuji
Would you like to receive bhagvat gita class .
I can send audio on hike or whatsapp .
Its very interesting and explained very scientifically .
This is the audio through which i started my bhakti . It will help you too
You can message me - 9762623334
hare krishna Radha Rasamayi and manikanta,
i would like to thank all the krishna devotee.
now i am going to assume that krishna is supreme .
now i will chant at least 4 round in a day.
but eating onion, garlics is not possible to leave because in my organization no any separate food is allow for particular person.
because i think no other way
and i will read bhagawatam when any doubt will come i will ask you.
i would ask you one question is that from mahabarat
how it is possible to born through fire(dropati or panchali) and all 5 pandu's sons and karn.without mother and father.
I can only say that you try to avoid onion garlic in food to the extent possible. If you are eating out, maybe you can ask what is tehre in the menu of this specification - no onion garlic and choose that and have. Once you demonstrate your sincerity to please the lord, you will get reciprocation and will be able to follow with ease.
I asked you to read Bhagavad Gita As It Is prabhuji. This is a dialogue betwen Lord Krishna & Arjuna on the battlefield of Kurukshetra. Srimad Bhagawatam, on the other hand, is the summary of the scriptures. In that, the 10 main avatars are mentioned alongwith a lot of stories about God. These are different scriptures - one is spoken by the lord, one is spoken of the lord. Gita is recommended to be read before one graduates to Bhagawatam.
Draupadi was not born from fire prabhuji. She was gifted to Drupad, when he was doing a fire sacrifice to get a son who kills Dronacharya. The way Dristadyumna came from fire, so did Draupadi. This means that they are from heaven. Why do we offer sacrifices in fire when we have to please the demigods? This is because it is mentioned in the scriptures that demigods accept offerings made in this loka through fire. In other words, fire is the mouth of the demigods. The way we can reach the demigods by putting offerings in the fire, they can reach us by giving gifts from fire at the time of sacrifice. This does not happen in Kaliyuga because this link is broken in this age.
The 6 sons born of Kunti & Madri put together had mother - no doubt about it. The father was - in each case, Sun, Dharma, Indra, Vayu, Ashwini Kumars. Therefore, mother and father both are there.
I hope I have answered your questions to your satisfaction. Pls ask if you have further doubts. Sorry for the late response. I was a little busy last week.
Haribol,
Your servant,
Radha Rasamayi DD
2h16li8uzbqmh > ashutosh kumar choubeyDecember 31, 2016 at 10:53am
onion garlic veg nonveg have no value in todays time. I have seen several nonveg eating people who are godly by nature and demonic selfish veg eaters. similarly those who don't eat onion garlic are actually most lusty debauchees. Its only to skip the hellish punishments people are recommended not to eat nonveg otherwise this all a sham. I wonder if there really are punishments for this!!
hare krishna Radha Rasamayi (Rashmi Khaitan) parbhu ji.
i would like to thank for all prabhu ji who is replying my post.
actually i am so confuse.
sometimes i want serve lord .and sometimes i question myself about past experience.
so prabhu ji give me direction .what i need to do for believe in god.
i know that theory and concept of science is regularly changing in some time period.
but since i am also science student i can realize the real truth of science and whatever written in script.
but i have lots of doubt on script also.
i know that i have little knowledge because i am unable to memorize script.
but doubt on script is restrict me to fallow script.
i want no any doubt should be in script.
only one doubt on script is adiquate to unfollow.
because script has god voice (directly or indirectly).
no any doubt should be.
but script is also so much confusing.
so please give me advise and direction where i can find my answer and start keeping faith on god.
prabhu ji don't think that i feel harsh .
whatever right or true please say without hesitate.
i am also hearting you.
because i am questioning about your believe and script.
may be my way is rude.moreover my english skill is not to good.may be problem in understanding my sentence.but i think you can guess exact meaning of my sentence.
I will try to explain in scientific way since you are more comfortable with science.
Suppose you are solving a geometry theoram - dont you start with a list of assumptions, then go about proving the theory and eventually the assumptions come out true.
Same way - start by assuming Krsna is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. So to establish a relationship with Krsna, one has to chant to awaken the dormant love for Him. So start chanting 4 rounds a day. This should take approx half an hour of your day. There are no rules to chanting - before or after taking bath, anytime of the day or night, any place, sitting, standing, walking.... no rules. Only rule is - you have to complete your rounds every single day before you go to sleep. The day you dont eat AND the day you dont sleep is the day you dont chant.
Alongwith chanting, you have to associate with devotees - I dont know if ISKCON has any program in your college - there is a lot of college preaching going on - pls find out, if there is any preaching happening in your college or outside the campus, within reach, pls join. You will learn a lot more when you see fellow students also following the path.
Thirdly, pls continue eating only veg food, without onion garlic, after it is offered to the lord.
Fourthly, pls read books - you could start with Chant Hare Krsna And Be Happy. Then go to Perfect Questions & Perfect Answers. When you are reading, you can ask any questions that come to your mind in this forum. It is a very active forum and you will get a lot of responses.
To continue answering your questions where I left last week - regarding Durga being supreme or Shiva being supreme - I understand it is very confusing to someone who is trying to find the right path. What I have understood is that - God has a form, He is not formless as the impersonalists think. How could we relate to someone who has no form, no qualities and is simply a vaccumm? Then how do we believe that He is listening to our prayers and is overseeing us? He has no form, right? Then howcome He has ears to hear and will to respond?
Durga has been clearly defined as the jailor of the material world called durg (fort). She is mahamaya, she is responsible for keeping us in illusion. That story you read about Brahma, Vishnu Mahesh being her kids - without seed giving father, how can she be mother? Who is the seed giving father? Shiva is mentioned as supreme in Shiva puran - has Shiva ever mentioned anywhere that he is supreme. Shiva has been mentioned as the param vaishnava in the Bhagawatam. Vaishnavanam param Shambhu....
On the contrary, Krsna has mentioned Himself in the Gita - I am supreme, there is no truth beyond Me. Then He proceeds to show His Vishwarupa to Arjuna. Is there mention of anyone else repeating this feat in any of the other scriptures you read or heard? That is why we believe Krsna is supreme. It is mentioned by Brahma in Brahma Samhita, so many established sages and seers of even our times call Krsna supreme.
I hope I have been able to convince you a little. I hope you will follow the process I have mentioned in this post.
Haribol,
Your servant,
Radha Rasamayi DD
2h16li8uzbqmh > ashutosh kumar choubeyDecember 25, 2016 at 9:09pm
Dear Sir,
RADHE KRISHNA RADHE SHYAM
from your comments I guess you were expecting a miracle from the lord to save your father. it does happen provided you remain faithful to the god. Don't feel bad prabhu but I feel you made a blunder chanting Mahamrityunjay mantra. MMJ mantra is the mantra of Lord Shiva. So when you chant MMJ you become disloyal to Krishna. Take examples of Prahlad maharaj he always stuck to Krishna till the last moment and was saved from death several times. Take e.x. of child Markandeya he stuck to Lord Shiva till the last moment and finally Yamraj had to go away by the orders of Shiva. Hanuman told Krishna that he wanted to see only his Lord Ram form. So one should always stick to one god or form or else its disrespect and disloyal to his worshipping diety. don't feel bad but I just said whatever I heard from pravachans and the e.x. I have given
2) ekadashi doesn't have a benediction that no human will die on that particular day.
3) thousands of people take false oath on gita every day in courts and give false evidence. this is kaliyuga dude. this will keep happening till the end. be careful next time.
4) yes all scriptures are manipulated beyond limit but Bhagvad Gita is direct msg of Krishna . you can surely rely on that. read "opulence of absolute" chapter, read what arjun observes and it will rid away all your doubts. hope this helps and sorry if you felt bad reading my comments.
O Lord,
Let those who misrepresent You, not lessen my faith in those who represent You properly.
Prayer is meant for the pleasure of Krishna.
Prabhu, you have very weak faith to stop believing in God just because your father died, your friend broke his promise, and God has yet to answer your prayers.
1. Everybody dies, but the spirit soul is eternal, and those who surrender to Krishna are never annihilated. Your father being a devotee, will never perish because devotees are dear to Krishna.
2. Your friend makes his own decisions, which may have nothing to do with you at all. Do not let his bad choices ruin your determination to come closer to God if that is actually what you want.
3. Krishna is under no obligation to answer you. We are eternally His servants and must try to please Him instead.
Often people think this way: "God has not answered my prayers, so he must not exist." What they do not realize is all that God has already done for them, and is still doing for them. And they also do not realize that we are meant to serve God, not be served by Him.
Pray for devotional service to the lotus feet of Radha and Krishna, again and again, and surely your prayer will be answered because Radha and Krishna are so infinitely merciful.
Prayers may be answered in time. But either way you have to trust that God will work everything out for the best, because He knows best. When a child asks his mother for a toy which is too dangerous, a good mother will deny the child this toy. The child, in ignorance, will think "my mother does not love me. She has not done as I asked." But in fact the mother loves the child so much that she is protecting him.
Similarly, Krishna knows what is best for us. So just because your prayers have not yet been answered, do not lose faith.
Replies
Those who are puffed up with material education, wealth, aristocracy and fruitive activity are very proud of possessing material things, and they often deride the true devotees. Even if such people offer the Lord worship, the Lord never accepts them.
Devotees who do not have material possessions, but are happy only with possessing devotional service, consider to be dear to Lord.
By showing mercy to all living entities and restricting the senses from sense enjoyment, one can very quickly satisfy the Lord. And when Lord is satisfied, what can not be achieved.
Would you like to receive bhagvat gita class .
I can send audio on hike or whatsapp .
Its very interesting and explained very scientifically .
This is the audio through which i started my bhakti . It will help you too
You can message me - 9762623334
Your servant
Radhe Radhe
YadavyahModdaviah Kashivah Nahmah
i would like to thank all the krishna devotee.
now i am going to assume that krishna is supreme .
now i will chant at least 4 round in a day.
but eating onion, garlics is not possible to leave because in my organization no any separate food is allow for particular person.
because i think no other way
and i will read bhagawatam when any doubt will come i will ask you.
i would ask you one question is that from mahabarat
how it is possible to born through fire(dropati or panchali) and all 5 pandu's sons and karn.without mother and father.
Hare Krsna Prabhuji,
PAMHO.
I can only say that you try to avoid onion garlic in food to the extent possible. If you are eating out, maybe you can ask what is tehre in the menu of this specification - no onion garlic and choose that and have. Once you demonstrate your sincerity to please the lord, you will get reciprocation and will be able to follow with ease.
I asked you to read Bhagavad Gita As It Is prabhuji. This is a dialogue betwen Lord Krishna & Arjuna on the battlefield of Kurukshetra. Srimad Bhagawatam, on the other hand, is the summary of the scriptures. In that, the 10 main avatars are mentioned alongwith a lot of stories about God. These are different scriptures - one is spoken by the lord, one is spoken of the lord. Gita is recommended to be read before one graduates to Bhagawatam.
Draupadi was not born from fire prabhuji. She was gifted to Drupad, when he was doing a fire sacrifice to get a son who kills Dronacharya. The way Dristadyumna came from fire, so did Draupadi. This means that they are from heaven. Why do we offer sacrifices in fire when we have to please the demigods? This is because it is mentioned in the scriptures that demigods accept offerings made in this loka through fire. In other words, fire is the mouth of the demigods. The way we can reach the demigods by putting offerings in the fire, they can reach us by giving gifts from fire at the time of sacrifice. This does not happen in Kaliyuga because this link is broken in this age.
The 6 sons born of Kunti & Madri put together had mother - no doubt about it. The father was - in each case, Sun, Dharma, Indra, Vayu, Ashwini Kumars. Therefore, mother and father both are there.
I hope I have answered your questions to your satisfaction. Pls ask if you have further doubts. Sorry for the late response. I was a little busy last week.
Haribol,
Your servant,
Radha Rasamayi DD
onion garlic veg nonveg have no value in todays time. I have seen several nonveg eating people who are godly by nature and demonic selfish veg eaters. similarly those who don't eat onion garlic are actually most lusty debauchees. Its only to skip the hellish punishments people are recommended not to eat nonveg otherwise this all a sham. I wonder if there really are punishments for this!!
i would like to thank for all prabhu ji who is replying my post.
actually i am so confuse.
sometimes i want serve lord .and sometimes i question myself about past experience.
so prabhu ji give me direction .what i need to do for believe in god.
i know that theory and concept of science is regularly changing in some time period.
but since i am also science student i can realize the real truth of science and whatever written in script.
but i have lots of doubt on script also.
i know that i have little knowledge because i am unable to memorize script.
but doubt on script is restrict me to fallow script.
i want no any doubt should be in script.
only one doubt on script is adiquate to unfollow.
because script has god voice (directly or indirectly).
no any doubt should be.
but script is also so much confusing.
so please give me advise and direction where i can find my answer and start keeping faith on god.
prabhu ji don't think that i feel harsh .
whatever right or true please say without hesitate.
i am also hearting you.
because i am questioning about your believe and script.
may be my way is rude.moreover my english skill is not to good.may be problem in understanding my sentence.but i think you can guess exact meaning of my sentence.
Hare Krsna Choubey ji,
PAMHO.
I will try to explain in scientific way since you are more comfortable with science.
Suppose you are solving a geometry theoram - dont you start with a list of assumptions, then go about proving the theory and eventually the assumptions come out true.
Same way - start by assuming Krsna is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. So to establish a relationship with Krsna, one has to chant to awaken the dormant love for Him. So start chanting 4 rounds a day. This should take approx half an hour of your day. There are no rules to chanting - before or after taking bath, anytime of the day or night, any place, sitting, standing, walking.... no rules. Only rule is - you have to complete your rounds every single day before you go to sleep. The day you dont eat AND the day you dont sleep is the day you dont chant.
Alongwith chanting, you have to associate with devotees - I dont know if ISKCON has any program in your college - there is a lot of college preaching going on - pls find out, if there is any preaching happening in your college or outside the campus, within reach, pls join. You will learn a lot more when you see fellow students also following the path.
Thirdly, pls continue eating only veg food, without onion garlic, after it is offered to the lord.
Fourthly, pls read books - you could start with Chant Hare Krsna And Be Happy. Then go to Perfect Questions & Perfect Answers. When you are reading, you can ask any questions that come to your mind in this forum. It is a very active forum and you will get a lot of responses.
To continue answering your questions where I left last week - regarding Durga being supreme or Shiva being supreme - I understand it is very confusing to someone who is trying to find the right path. What I have understood is that - God has a form, He is not formless as the impersonalists think. How could we relate to someone who has no form, no qualities and is simply a vaccumm? Then how do we believe that He is listening to our prayers and is overseeing us? He has no form, right? Then howcome He has ears to hear and will to respond?
Durga has been clearly defined as the jailor of the material world called durg (fort). She is mahamaya, she is responsible for keeping us in illusion. That story you read about Brahma, Vishnu Mahesh being her kids - without seed giving father, how can she be mother? Who is the seed giving father? Shiva is mentioned as supreme in Shiva puran - has Shiva ever mentioned anywhere that he is supreme. Shiva has been mentioned as the param vaishnava in the Bhagawatam. Vaishnavanam param Shambhu....
On the contrary, Krsna has mentioned Himself in the Gita - I am supreme, there is no truth beyond Me. Then He proceeds to show His Vishwarupa to Arjuna. Is there mention of anyone else repeating this feat in any of the other scriptures you read or heard? That is why we believe Krsna is supreme. It is mentioned by Brahma in Brahma Samhita, so many established sages and seers of even our times call Krsna supreme.
I hope I have been able to convince you a little. I hope you will follow the process I have mentioned in this post.
Haribol,
Your servant,
Radha Rasamayi DD
Dear Sir,
RADHE KRISHNA RADHE SHYAM
from your comments I guess you were expecting a miracle from the lord to save your father. it does happen provided you remain faithful to the god. Don't feel bad prabhu but I feel you made a blunder chanting Mahamrityunjay mantra. MMJ mantra is the mantra of Lord Shiva. So when you chant MMJ you become disloyal to Krishna. Take examples of Prahlad maharaj he always stuck to Krishna till the last moment and was saved from death several times. Take e.x. of child Markandeya he stuck to Lord Shiva till the last moment and finally Yamraj had to go away by the orders of Shiva. Hanuman told Krishna that he wanted to see only his Lord Ram form. So one should always stick to one god or form or else its disrespect and disloyal to his worshipping diety. don't feel bad but I just said whatever I heard from pravachans and the e.x. I have given
2) ekadashi doesn't have a benediction that no human will die on that particular day.
3) thousands of people take false oath on gita every day in courts and give false evidence. this is kaliyuga dude. this will keep happening till the end. be careful next time.
4) yes all scriptures are manipulated beyond limit but Bhagvad Gita is direct msg of Krishna . you can surely rely on that. read "opulence of absolute" chapter, read what arjun observes and it will rid away all your doubts. hope this helps and sorry if you felt bad reading my comments.
THANKS
BR,
Suhas Patil
Let those who misrepresent You, not lessen my faith in those who represent You properly.
Prayer is meant for the pleasure of Krishna.
Prabhu, you have very weak faith to stop believing in God just because your father died, your friend broke his promise, and God has yet to answer your prayers.
1. Everybody dies, but the spirit soul is eternal, and those who surrender to Krishna are never annihilated. Your father being a devotee, will never perish because devotees are dear to Krishna.
2. Your friend makes his own decisions, which may have nothing to do with you at all. Do not let his bad choices ruin your determination to come closer to God if that is actually what you want.
3. Krishna is under no obligation to answer you. We are eternally His servants and must try to please Him instead.
Often people think this way: "God has not answered my prayers, so he must not exist." What they do not realize is all that God has already done for them, and is still doing for them. And they also do not realize that we are meant to serve God, not be served by Him.
Pray for devotional service to the lotus feet of Radha and Krishna, again and again, and surely your prayer will be answered because Radha and Krishna are so infinitely merciful.
Prayers may be answered in time. But either way you have to trust that God will work everything out for the best, because He knows best. When a child asks his mother for a toy which is too dangerous, a good mother will deny the child this toy. The child, in ignorance, will think "my mother does not love me. She has not done as I asked." But in fact the mother loves the child so much that she is protecting him.
Similarly, Krishna knows what is best for us. So just because your prayers have not yet been answered, do not lose faith.
-
1
-
2
-
3
of 3 Next