Forum

Jambu-Dvip comprises of nine khands : 

Ilavart-Khand, Ketumal-Khand, Ramyak Khand, Hiranyamay-Khand, Kuru-Khand, Bhadrashva-Khand, Harivarsh-Khand, Kimpurush-Khand and Bharat-Khand. These are the nine khands of Jambu-Dvip. 

We know about the Bharat khand but can anyone please give the modern geographical names of rest 8 khands or continents ?

You need to be a member of ISKCON Desire Tree | IDT to add comments!

Join ISKCON Desire Tree | IDT

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Hare Krsna, my humble obeisances.

    In the Srimad Bhagavatam, 5th canto, the other 8 varsas of Jambudvipa are described as bhauma-svarga, which means earthly heavens. There the inhabitants have bodily characteristics and ambiental circumstances that are far beyond what we see now on earth. So those regions are other-dimensional, and unaccessible to our senses. I don't think they might be exactly geografically located on the earth as we know it, although certain geographical links with some of them seem to exist on our earth. They are touched upon by Prabhupada in his commentary on 1.16.12. One should also read the canto 5 chapters 16-19.  

    YsY

    • Hare Krishna Prabhuji,

      PAMHO,

      It is mentioned in the Mahabharata that Arjuna, during his conquest of northern kingdoms also visited the Kimpurusha Kingdom. After crossing the White mountains, he subjugated the country of the Kimpurushas ruled by Durmaputra, after a collision involving a great slaughter of Kshatriyas, he brought the region under his complete sway. 

      Hence, if Bharat khand, which is a part of Jambu dwip can be located and it's residents can be perceived by normal senses, then as per the above instance from Mahabharata, the residents of other khands should be definitely perceivable by senses. There must be some modern geographical names for them.

      • To Arjuna's senses, yes. I would't say that it necessarily follows that we should be able to perceive it too. From a number of instances in Bhagavatam it appears that the people in previous yugas had perceptive and physical access to much a wider area of earthly reality than we do now. Dhruva Maharaja (Satya-yuga) reigned the entire Bhu-Mandala. Yudhisthira (Dvapara ending) reigned the entire Jambudvipa. And Arjuna is still more special case. He was able to go to the stars, to wander among them and watch them face to face, and also to visit the devas.

        Besides, Bharata-varsa is originally the whole planet that we deal with. Only in Kali-yuga the name Bharata has been restricted to nowadays India. Originally, however, the whole globe is Bharata. So, if we want to locate the other varsas within this planet, it means we want to locate other varsas within Bharata-varsa. That is not logical, as they are clearly described as separated from it by means of enormously high mountain ranges.

        However, Arjuna did enter from our Bharata into other regions. That's why i wrote that it appears that there are links, within Bharata geography, with other varsas, or let's say entrances into other varsas. Madhvacarya accessed to the Uttara-badarikasrama to see Vyasadeva face to face, by climbing into the Himalayas. But that Badarikasrama is inaccessible by us. If someone doesn't believe, let him try (better not, i'm joking). Everything there was so different from what he had experienced previosly. So even Bharata is not fully accessed by us Kaliyuga humans (it is described in the SB 5 that in the Bharata there is Narada instructing the future Manu on the science of self realization), what to speak about the other varsas, which are of still higher status.

        I hope you find this as intriguing as do i.

        Your humble servant

        YJd

        • Dear Yamuna Jivana Prabhuji,

          There is a difference between khand (i.e a continent) and a planet. Bharat Varsha is a 'khand' i.e a continent and hence we can not call it a planet (or a 'graha'). However, we can call Jambu dwip as 'graha' or planet. 

          Let's assume that Bharata Varsha is originally the whole planet. So, what are the Vedic names for Asia, Africa, North-America, South-America, Antarctica, Europe and Australia i.e 7 continents or 'khands'? 

          Interestingly, I have stumped upon the following image :

          2545079407?profile=original 

          For more details, kindly click the below link :

          http://decodehindumythology.blogspot.in/2012/02/jambudweep-global-i...

          I hope you will find this an enriching experience !

          Hare Krishna !

          • Hare Krsna, Prabhu Krsna Mukherji.

            Please don't mind me, but i fail to see how your points are sastric.

            Who and where have defined the "khanda" as continent?

            You seem to say that only "grahas" can be called planets. However, grahas are 9, well defined in Surya Siddhanta, and they hold, besides a cosmographical significance, also an astrological significance ("grah" means to "hold", indicating the holding of the sway upon the destinies of individuals). Planets, however, are innumerable and all over the universe. More appropriate term for a planet is "loka", and you will find such a translation throughout the Bhagavatam.

            As far as Bharata, whether you term it a khand or a varsh, it can rightfully be called a planet, because it has the dimensions and characteristics of a planet, and is said to be this whole planet in a number of places in Srimad Bhagavatam. To give you a few: 1.12.20, 2.7.10, 3.18.19 (look in the purports), and there are many more. 

            As far as the vedic names for the 7 continents, i do not know them. I do not know even if the continents as we know them now were at all there in the remote past, or if the earth had a pretty diverse geographical shape. In which way is it authorized to give the names of Jambudvipas' varsas to our continents?

            The same questions holds for the image you have stumped upon. Where in the ancient texts are the 9 varsas of Jambudvipa equated to the geographical regions of our globe as marked on the image? And where is the Jambudvipa equated to our globe itself? Quite on the contrary, Srimad Bhagavatam defines Jambudvipa to be a tract of land whose dimensions are far far greater than the dimensions of our globe. And the khandas of Jambudvipa have dimensions far far larger than the dimensions of our continents. As far as the dimensions given, there's a drastic difference. Please read carefully the relevant portions of the 5th canto.

            (It is true that even the Bharata-varsa from SB is quite bigger than the dimensions of our globe. We don't deny it. Our globe is, therefore, only one part of the whole Bharata-varsa of which the Bhagavatam speaks. Prabhupada had admitted that "Modern scientists... indeed, are hardly conversant with the planet on which we are now living. 5.20.37 pp)

            Finally, as far as the link you offer, even at the first glance it gives a very pro-western impression. It's title "decode hindu mythology" indicates clearly that they consider Puranic and Mahabharata accounts as mythology, as just some methaphorical stories which are in need to be decoded by some smart person. While the Puranas themselves, and the Mahabharata itself, and the Ramayana itself, and so on, all of them are quite clear in considering themselves to be  true accounts of true events, and true descriptions of true situations. And the acaryas of guru-parampara confirm stalwartly the same. And both warn us seriously, that if we are willing to take our sensory perception as the verdict of reality, we are closing our consciousness into a cave completely cut-off from what reality really is.

            The site you mention does contain some useful information, it is undeniable, even plenty of those, and is very carefully and nicely done. However, it seems to be neglecting the data non favorable to the picture the author wants to draw, as for example the dimensions i mentioned from the Bhagavatam. And its basic premises seem to be misleading. So i would hesitate to be following the views from the site just on account of being charmed by the (undeniable) beauty of the site. Sadaputa Prabhu gives fairer and more complete views in his book "Mysteries of the Sacred Universe". Another excellent book by Sadaputa P is mentioned by Gaur Gadadhar Prabhu -- "Vedic Cosmography and Astronomy."  

            Hare Krsna

            Your humble servant

            YJd

             

          • Volunteer

             


             

            Vedic Cosmography and Astronomy


             

             
            By Richard L. Thompson

            Published by Motilal Banarsidass Publ., 2003
            ISBN 8120819543, 9788120819542

            Click to see Full Book: >>>>>>


            Mysteries of the Sacred Universe
            The Cosmology of the Bhagavata Purana
            Please wait for this video!!!


            Contents


            The Astronomical Siddhantas ...........................7
            yojanas , Aryabhata , astronomical

            Vedic Cosmography ...........................47
            Jambudvipa , Mount Meru , celestial equator

            The Vertical Dimension ...........................83
            Rahu , ecliptic , Svarga

            The Empirical Case for the Vedic World System ...........................105
            Cova da Iria , Jacques Vallee , Danava

            Modern Astrophysics and the Vedic Perspective ...........................119
            vimanas , classical physics , Sumeru

            Red Shifts and the Expanding Universe ...........................145
            red shifts , quasars , Hubble constant

            Questions and Answers ...........................161
            jyotisa , Jambudvipa , Puranas

            Appendix ...........................181
            Hipparchus , Indian astronomy , mean longitudes

            Bibliography ...........................201
            Redshift Quantization , Bhaktivedanta Book Trust , Galaxy Dynamics



            Popular passages


            THE PLANET NEPTUNE is NOT THE PLANET TO WHICH GEOMETRICAL ANALYSIS HAD DIRECTED THE TELESCOPE ; that its orbit is not contained within the limits of space which have been explored by geometers searching for the source of the disturbances of Uranus ; and that its discovery by Galle must be regarded as a happy accident.‎ - Page 126
            Appears in 29 books from 1844-2003

            But what are they 1 for others greater still Have passed away, vast oceans have been dried, Mountains thrown down, the polar star displaced, The cords that bind the planets rent asunder, The whole earth deluged with a flood of water, E'en highest angels driven from their stations. In such a world what relish can there be For true enjoyment ' deign to rescue us , Thou only art our refuge, holy lord...‎ - Page 101
            Appears in 11 books from 1875-2006

            Brahma and all the gods bow in reverence, holds his favourite residence. " Beyond the sea of milk lie, in succession, the seas of curds, clarified butter, sugar-cane juice, and wine, and, last of all, that of sweet water, which surrounds Vadavanala.‎ - Page 69
            Appears in 9 books from 1861-2003

            ... results to be controlled or corrected by evidence of any other character. He had, in fact, no philology, and he was deficient in sound critical judgment. He thoroughly misapprehended the character of the Hindu astronomical literature, thinking it to be, in the main, a mass of forgeries framed for the purpose of deceiving the world respecting the antiquity of the Hindu people.‎ - Page 16
            Appears in 5 books from 1851-2003

            Seas, viz., those of salt, milk, &c., are all situated in the southern hemisphere. " To the south of the equator lies the salt sea, and, to the south of it, the sea of milk, whence...‎ - Page 69
            Appears in 8 books from 1861-2003

            Recapitulating, we may say that according to the general theory of relativity space is endowed with physical qualities ; in this sense, therefore, there exists an ether. According to the general theory of relativity space without ether is unthinkable...‎ - Page 135
            Appears in 34 books from 1922-2007

            According to the general theory of relativity space without ether is unthinkable ; for in such space there not only would be no propagation of light, but also no possibility of existence for standards of space and time (measuring-rods and clocks), nor therefore any space-time intervals in the physical sense.‎ - Page 135
            Appears in 26 books from 1922-2007

            Charlemagne's enemy, to destroy the French -^ harvests. In vain the four innocents sought to vindicate themselves by saying that they were their own countryfolk, and had been carried away a short time since by miraculous men who had shown them unheard-of marvels, and had desired them to give an account of what they had seen. The frenzied populace paid no heed to their defence, and were on the point of casting them into the fire when the worthy Agobard, Bishop...‎ - Page 114
            Appears in 6 books from 1913-2005

            ... man who partakes of my nature will impart to you the whole of the science. 7. The God Sun, having thus spoken to, and ordered the man born from himself (to teach MAYA), disappeared. That man spoke to MAYA, who stood bending and folding his hands close to his forehead, in the following manner. 8. (0 MAYA), hear attentively the excellent knowledge (of the science of Astronomy) which the Sun himself formerly taught to the great saints in each of the YUGAS. 9. I teach you the same ancient science,...‎ - Page 22
            Appears in 5 books from 1861-2003

            ... and destruction of the manifested universes. He is directly and indirectly conscious of all manifestations, and He is independent because there is no other cause beyond Him. It is He only who first imparted the Vedic knowledge unto the heart of Lord Brahma, the first created living being.‎ - Page 33
            Appears in 4 books from 1987-2005

This reply was deleted.