1.how earth is originated?how life is originated?explain according to scinteific as well as spiritual point of view.
2.why prabhupad says rascal again and again?a devotee never blastpheme others.
3.animals and trees both r living both have soul.if u can not kill animal as thear is soul so hpw can we kill trees?soul is also in trees.
4.my friends says krsna can lift up goverdhan we can lift up a small stone similarly krsna have 1008 queens so we can also have some girls what is the problem?explain.
Replies
1.how earth is originated?how life is originated?explain according to scinteific as well as spiritual point of view.
answer: adding SP conversation
Dr. Singh, December 3, 1973: The scientists say that at one point the earth was composed of dust particles floating in some gaseous material. Then, in due course, this colloidal suspension condensed and formed the earth.
Srila Prabhupada: That may be, but where did the gas come from?
Dr. Singh: They say it just existed!
Srila Prabhupada: Krishna says in Bhagavad-gita (7.4):
“Earth, water, fire, air, ether, mind, intelligence and false ego–all together these eight comprise My separated material energies.”
Here Krishna explains that vayu (gas) came from Him. And finer than vayu is kham (ether), finer than ether is mind, finer than mind is intelligence, finer than intelligence is false ego, and finer than false ego is the soul. But the scientists do not know this. They understand only gross things. They mention gas, but where does the gas come from?
Dr. Singh: That they cannot answer.
Srila Prabhupada: But we can answer. From Srimad-Bhagavatam we know that gas has come from kham, or ether, ether comes from mind, mind comes from intelligence, intelligence comes from false ego, and false ego comes from the soul.
2.why prabhupad says rascal again and again?a devotee never blastpheme others.
answer: he called rascle by rascle what is problem, he didn't blaspheme he told truth he is empowered soul (shaktyavesh avataar) krishna spoke through him for paramhamsa no rules dear rules are for sadhakas . by calling someone by rascle he benefitted person eternally .i become very happy (i feel like nector) when i hear rascle it shows he is great concern and selfless love for person.
this is mood and attitude of SP i like this style SP very much.
3.animals and trees both r living both have soul.if u can not kill animal as thear is soul so how can we kill trees?soul is also in trees.
answer: i m fully agree but remember the degree of conscousness is less in plants compare to animals and we don't eat person but body and plants are prescribed food for us in plants also we ignore high protein food like soyabean etc
tiger eats flesh no issues bcoz it is his prescribed food any other animal doesn't get reaction bcoz they r suffering at that time human body where we become responsible for actions. one thing if onw eat only plants still it is sin bcoz it is not offered.
still i haven't answered q'n if one eats animal (offered or not offered) may be bcoz no other food is available sure he will become resp. for karma whatever circumstances loop hole is become devotee end material game start spiritaul life.
4.my friends says krsna can lift up goverdhan we can lift up a small stone similarly krsna have 1008 queens so we can also have some girls what is the problem?explain.
answer: krishna have 16108 queens and unlimited girl friends and all very full of satisfaction bcoz krishna is not ordinary person HE IS SUPREME GOD and the real husband of every living entity* including we all. pran rakshati iti pati and he is charachar pati. lord shiva & mother durga wants to be his girl friends.
if krishna does we can do is bad bcoz many*** krishnalilas are not for imitation
In special cases if one can give respect to all wives and genuine reason for marriage is there like women doesn't have sheltor or deadly disease or women approach person without force and with her consent*** one can get in to relation but that doesn't mean he or she will be permanently happy OK suffering is guranteed. only devotional service can make one permanant happy rest is temporary.don't take it as license one marraige is recommended in general.
1. from the sound vibration "AUM"
2. For example can we call stool as perfume? No! In this way we have to call things by their nature. We were and are still rascals who think that we are God or this body.
3. Then lets not to eat anything! yes it is a great sin, but for example soldier can kill hundreds of enemies and won't be put into jail because he was ordered to do so. But if You and me kill even one person then for whole life we will be imprisoned because we were not ordered to do so but we did.
Krishna told to offer to Him and eat trees then why not to do so?
4. Krishna had wives. And we also should have wives not some girls. They can get citizenship of that country where it is legal and get married up to 4 wives. Then i am sure they never ever will put this question.
Your servant,
Hare Krishna Abhinav prabhu,
1. I am afraid that I may not be able to give you perfect answer.
2. Prabhupada said because Krishna says in Bhagavad-Gita
Na mam duskrtino mudhah prapadyante naradhamah [Bg. 7.15].
These are the qualifications of persons who do not surrender to Krishna: miscreants, mischievous, sinful, mudha, rascal, asses, naradhama, lowest of the mankind. These are the qualifications. So they are all durbuddhi.
3. Krishna orders us to take foods from the categories of fruits, vegetables, dairy products, and grains and to offer to them to Him before eating. If we offer such foods to Krishna before eating, He relieves us of the sinful reaction of killing the plant and transforms the foodstuffs from matter into spirit for the sanctification of our consciousness. He assures of this in the Bhagavad-gita. But He makes no such concession for the eating of meat, fish, and eggs. Because they are not offerable to Krishna, if we eat them, we are only eating lumps of sin, and we will suffer karmic reactions.
4. Krishna was married to 16,108 princesses. He was present in every one house personally. That means He expanded Himself in 16,108 forms. I heard the same nonsense talk from Zakir Naik if Krishna can have 16108 wives why we shouldn't have four..? That is a nonsense talk.. Muslim people were addicted to sex life and meat eating so it was an option given to Muslim people but they will never understand..Everyone wants sense gratification.. Never ever compare human beings with God.. We are most fallen souls as we have done so many sin's in our life..
Please correct me if I am wrong.
Your eternal servant,
Karthick
Haribol. AGSTP. PAMHO.
In your comment about muslim practices, I'm afraid you have taken a very bigoted viewpoint.
Anyway, to put it practically, Mohamedanism originated in the Middle East, which I'm sure you are aware is a very arid area. Due to extreme aridity, there was not enough water to grow edible crops and vegetables satisfactorily, so they had to resort to a meat diet. They also ate grains, and vegetables, but meat was the center of their meal - because it was easy to get. They also drained the blood out of the meat to ensure that instead of rotting, it dries - this made the meat edible even after some time - since there was no refrigeration available in those times.
Secondly, mortality rate was very high in these medieval times, more so in the middle east due to the extreme climate, lack of water for sanitation and lack of proper medical care. Middle eastern people led a nomadic life and this led to the creation of silo'ed societies. It had so happened, that due to the spread of disease, entire bedouin tribes vanished - with no lineage of society left. As a result, they were asked to marry more than one woman, to ensure a greater number of children - just to beat the odds of getting wiped out with sheer numbers.
The fact is, all these so called rules were applicable in that time and age, but now things have improved. However, because of religious rigidity, Muslims follow the same old customs even now. It didn't seem out of place then, but it seems out of place now.
Even if we could evolve out of following scriptures blindly, maybe we would be viewed as more acceptable to other members of society.