ISKCON Desire Tree - Devotee Network

Connecting Devotees Worldwide - In Service Of Srila Prabhupada

LECTURE ON THE SRIMAD BHAGAVAD-GITA, SECOND CHAPTER,TEXT NINETEEN, BY HIS HOLINESS BHAKTI CARU SWAMI

THE FOLLOWING LECTURE ON THE SRIMAD BHAGAVAD-GITA, SECOND CHAPTER,
TEXT NINETEEN, WAS GIVEN BY HIS HOLINESS BHAKTI CARU SWAMI IN ISKCON
LAGUNA BEACH, US, ON 1 JULY 2011.



Transcription : Her Grace Ranga Radhika Dasi and Her Grace Syama
Mohini Dasi

Editing : Ramananda Raya Dasa

Audio-reference :
http://www.bcswami.com/2011/07/20/lectures-in-laguna-beach-and-san-...

Om Namo Bhagavate Vasudevaya
Om Namo Bhagavate Vasudevaya
Om Namo Bhagavate Vasudevaya

Narayanam namaskritya
Naram caiva narottamam
Devim saraswatim vyasam
Tato jayam udirayet

So, Bhagavad Gita, Second Chapter, text nineteen.
ya enam vetti hantaram
yas cainam manyate hatam
ubhau tau na vijanito
nayam hanti na hanyate

SYNONYMS
yah – anyone who; enam – this; vetti – knows; hantaram – the killer;
yah- anyone who; ca – also; enam – this; manyate – thinks; hatam –
killed; ubhau – both; tau – they; na – never; vijanitah – are in
knowledge; na – never; ayam – this; hanti – kills; na – nor; hanyate –
is killed.

TRANSLATION
Neither he who thinks the living entity the slayer nor he who thinks
it slain is in knowledge, for the self slays not nor is slain.

PURPORT
When an embodied living entity is hurt by fatal weapons, it is to be
known that the living entity within the body is not killed. The spirit
soul is so small that it is impossible to kill him by any material
weapon, as will be evident from subsequent verses. Nor is the living
entity killable, because of his spiritual constitution. What is
killed, or is supposed to be killed, is the body only. This, however,
does not at all encourage killing of the body. The Vedic injunction is
ma himsyat sarva bhutani: never commit violence to anyone. Nor does
understanding that the living entity is not killed encourage animal
slaughter. Killing the body of anyone without authority is abominable
and is punishable by the law of the state as well as by the law of the
Lord. Arjuna, however, is being engaged in killing for the principle
of religion, and not whimsically.
[End of Purport]
ya enam vetti hantaram
yas cainam manyate hatam
ubhau tau na vijanito
nayam hanti na hanyate
So, Arjuna at the battlefield of Kurukshetra refused to fight the
battle. Just when the battle was about to begin both the armies were
facing each other in the holy land of Kurukshetra. The conchshell was
already blown. That means the war has already begun. And at that point
Arjuna seeing that in the enemy line his intimate relatives and
friends are standing as his enemies, he became so overwhelmed with
compassion and emotion that he told Krishna that he couldn’t fight the
battle.

He saw his grandfather, Bhishma. He saw his guru, Dronacarya. He saw
his friends, and uncles and cousins standing in the enemy line like
Duryodhana, Ashvatthama, Kripacarya, Shalva. They were all very, very
closely related to each other. Arjuna was practically brought up at
the lap of Bhishma and now he is standing against him. And this battle
was so terrible and the battle was so fierce that it was a matter of
either kill or getting killed. A warrior never thinks that he is going
to get killed. He thinks that he is going to kill everybody. So
Arjuna’s mood at that time and Arjuna’s feeling at that time was, that
how could I possibly release arrows to kill these individuals who are
so close to me.

katham bhishmam aham sankhye
dronam ca madhusudana
ishubhih pratiyotsyami
pujarhav ari-sudana
[Bg. 2.4]
Katham, how can I in this [unclear], in this war, ishubhih
pratiyotsyami, release my arrows to Bhishma, dronam ca madhusudana,
and Drona as well. Because they are pujarhav, they are my worshipable
spiritual gurus, spiritual master and grandfather. Pujarhav
ari-sudana, they are my worshipable lords and relatives.

In this way Arjuna was giving many reasons and arguments why to fight
this battle was not possible for him. But at the end Arjuna actually
submitted to Krishna. He told Him that, “I don’t know what I should
do. I am accepting You as my spiritual master. So You please tell me
what I should do. Please guide me.” At that point Krishna started to
advise Arjuna.

Prabhupada mentioned that Krishna did not say anything to Arjuna until
Arjuna accepted Him as guru and submitted himself to Him. And when he
did that then Krishna started to tell him. And what was the first
thing that Krishna told him? Krishna told him that, “Look, you are
lamenting over things that one should not lament about. Asocayan
anvasocas tvam [Bg. 2.11] Yes, prajna-vadams va bhasase, you are
speaking like prajna-vadams, speaking like a pandita, speaking like a
wise man. You are speaking like a wise man but actually you don’t have
any knowledge. You are lamenting over something that one shouldn’t
lament about. And gatasun agatasums ca nanusocanti panditah. One who
is really situated in knowledge doesn’t lament about something that is
transient and perishable. And then Krishna started to explain to
Arjuna the science of Bhagavad Gita.

From verse…in this chapter, second chapter actually, Krishna started
to advise Arjuna. Verse twelve onwards and today we are discussing
about the nineteenth verse. In previous seven verses Krishna gave
enough information to Arjuna about the permanent nature of the soul
and the transient, perishable nature of the body. So in this way
Krishna is actually explaining to Arjuna the difference between matter
and spirit. We are in a world of matter, material world. This is the
world of matter and by nature matter is inert, dead matter. Matter is
dead. Matter is inert. Matter is unconscious. Matter is devoid of
life. But in this world of dead matter you see some living things. Why
and how? That is what Krishna actually established. Like, the body is
made of matter but it is due to the presence of the soul that the body
made of dead matter is alive. This is the first thing that Bhagavad
Gita is establishing or this science is establishing: to understand
the difference between matter and spirit. This seat where I am
sitting, asana, is inert matter. This table is inert. This microphone
is inert. The wall is inert. But we all are living. What causes us to
be alive? To understand that, we can consider that when someone dies,
although his body maybe lying there, but we say, “He is gone.” He is
gone. Although his lying there we say, “He is gone.” So who is that
‘he’? Whose departure from the body made the body become dead? To
begin with it is a dead body. A body made of dead matter is a dead
body but it is due to the presence of the soul that the body is alive,
meaning the body becomes conscious. It is a very simple common sense
matter but we fail to recognize this point until we come across
scriptures like Bhagavad Gita and teachers like Srila Prabhupada.
Many of us, especially those of you who are coming from India and you
few who are from the West also must have read Bhagavad Gita before. I
read about seven different Bhagavad Gitas before coming across
Prabhupada’s Bhagavad Gita As It Is. I used to carry a Bhagavad Gita
with me and I used to read from Bhagavad Gita, take note from Bhagavad
Gita and I used to think I am understanding so much from Bhagavad
Gita. But when I came across Srila Prabhupada’s Bhagavad Gita I
realized that I didn’t understand anything of Bhagavad Gita.

In this respect I recall one incidence. One of Prabhupada’s first
disciples was Brahmananda prabhu. Those days Prabhupada used to live
at the back of twenty sixth Second Avenue in a small apartment. And in
the front there was the ‘Matchless Gifts’. There Prabhupada used to
give discourses on the Bhagavad Gita in the evening. So one day
Brahmananda prabhu, who was a teacher, school teacher, was passing by
and he saw this. And he got to know the Swami is here, he is giving
these courses on Bhagavad Gita in the evening. So he wanted to meet
the Swami, Srila Prabhupada. And he went to Srila Prabhupada. He had
an appointment. Prabhupada was ready to see him. So when he went to
Srila Prabhupada he tried to impress Srila Prabhupada by saying that
he also read Bhagavad Gita and he had a Bhagavad Gita with him also.
So Prabhupada was naturally impressed, but Prabhupada told him, “Okay,
just open any page of the Bhagavad Gita”, that he was carrying. So he
opened that page, just opened one page like that and Prabhupada said,
“Read.” So he read and Prabhupada said, “Close the book.” He closed
the book. Prabhupada said, “Tell me what you understood.” And
Brahmananda realized that he didn’t understand anything! [laughter]
And then Prabhupada explained that to understand Bhagavad Gita you
need a bona fide teacher, a qualified teacher. A bona fide spiritual
master. And that kind of bona fide spiritual masters are rare in this
world, who really understand Bhagavad Gita. Srila Prabhupada is one
such rare spiritual master and Srila Prabhupada came and he presented
Bhagavad Gita As It Is. Why Prabhupada’s Bhagavad Gita is entitled as
‘Bhagavad Gita As It Is’? How many of you know? How many of you want
to know? Okay! [Laughs] If you add ‘It Is’, Prabhupada explains ‘As It
Is’ meaning the way Krishna gave it and the way Arjuna understood it.
That is what makes Bhagavad Gita ‘As It Is’: the way Krishna spoke and
the way Arjuna understood it.

There are many Bhagavad Gitas. I remember in 1976 actually we took a
survey. I was new in the movement. Tukarama prabhu while introducing
me told I joined in 1976 and we were making a survey of Bhagavad Gita
and we found that there were more than 250 translations of Bhagavad
Gita. And we also noted that all those 250 Bhagavad Gitas put together
did not make a single devotee of Krishna, whereas Srila Prabhupada’s
one Bhagavad Gita As It Is was making thousands of devotees, now maybe
hundreds of thousands of devotees all over the world. Not only
hundreds of thousands, more than that, millions of devotees all over
the world. That is the potency of Srila Prabhupada’s Bhagavad Gita.
Most of the Bhagavad Gitas what they did was they took the words of
Krishna but they gave their interpretation. Not the way Arjuna
understood, they accepted the way Krishna spoke, but they did not
accept the way Arjuna understood it. They did their speculation. Oh,
Krishna is this, Krishna is that. Bhagavad Gita means this and so on
and so forth. But Prabhupada’s Bhagavad Gita is the authentic Bhagavad
Gita, the bona fide Bhagavad Gita because it is presenting Arjuna’s
understanding of this wisdom that is spoken by Krishna. Bhagavad Gita
was given to Arjuna, it was for him to understand and act accordingly.
And we in order to derive the specific benefit out of the Bhagavad
Gita we have to follow that course, the way Arjuna understood.

In Bhagavad Gita Mahatmya, in the glorification of Bhagavad Gita,
describing the essence of Bhagavad Gita, it has been mentioned
“sarvopanishado gavo”, all the Upanishads have been compared to a cow.
Dogdha gopalanandana, and who gave the cow? Upanishad is a cow and the
milker of that cow is Gopala Krishna, Krishna. And this cow gives the
milk for the sake of the calf, Arjuna. Arjuna is the calf of this cow.
And those who are really intelligent, those who are seriously
concerned about their spiritual welfare they drink this milk of
Bhagavad Gita. They drink this nectar of Bhagavad Gita.

sarvopanishado gavo dogdha gopalanandana
parthovatsa sudhirbhoktha dugdham gitamrtam mahat

This dugdham Gita, Gita is a milk which is like amrtam. What is the
characteristic of nectar? What is the specific quality of nectar? The
Sanskrit word for nectar is ‘amrta’. Amrta means negation of death.
Negation of death, meaning immortality. You read Bhagavad Gita you
become immortal. You’ll achieve immortality. That is the real purpose
of Bhagavad Gita. How? As you are reading now, Krishna is pointing out
that the body is perishable. Body dies but the soul is immortal.
The next verse you will see that point very clearly: na jayate mriyate
va kadacin [Bg 2.20]. This spirit soul is never born nor will it ever
die. Na jayate means it is never born. Mriyate va kadacin, nor will it
ever die. Ajo nityah sasvato ‘yam purano na hanyate na hanyamane
sarire. Even if the body is slain, even if the body is killed the soul
cannot be killed. Soul may leave the body. In a certain condition when
the body is severed by some weapon or body is burned by fire then the
soul may leave the body and when the soul leaves the body, body dies
but the soul never dies. And what is our real identity? Our actual
identity is the body or the soul? [audience: soul] Very good! How many
of you think that you are a spirit soul? Thank you. And the soul is
immortal. How many of you accept that the soul is immortal? Thank you!
So you are a spirit soul and the soul is immortal. Therefore you are…?
[audience: immortal] So you reached your immortality? [audience: yes!]
Right from the second chapter of Bhagavad Gita you reached
immortality! [laughter] Dughdam gitamrtam mahat, this great, nectarian
milk of the Bhagavad Gita gives us immortality. Drink it and become
immortal. But how do you drink this nectar? Some things you drink with
your mouth and some things else you drink with your ears. You drink
this nectar of Bhagavad Gita through your ears and you will achieve
immortality.
So in the second chapter that is what Krishna is doing, at the
beginning of the second chapter. Krishna is reminding Arjuna and
through Arjuna Krishna is actually reminding us. This is an important
point to also consider through this analogy of the milk of the cow.
Although the cow gives milk for the sake of the calf but the calf
doesn’t drink all the milk. Those who have any experience with cows
you know that if the calf drinks all the milk of the cow or if the
calf drinks too much of the milk the calf becomes sick. So that means
it’s nature’s arrangement that cow’s milk is meant for human beings.
Cow gives the milk, of course the calf is the impetus for the milk of
the cow, but it is meant for the human beings to drink.
So similarly, Krishna gave Bhagavad Gita to Arjuna that the actual
purpose of Bhagavad Gita is for human beings to drink it. Sudhi,
sudhi. Wich people, with individuals drink this milk. Sudhi. Dhi means
intelligence. And su means very advanced, very developed. Also it
means very beautiful. So whose intelligence is advanced, whose
intelligence is active and whose intelligence is beautiful, Bhagavad
Gita is meant for them. It is meant for those individuals.
It needs a certain degree of intelligence to actually understand and
appreciate Bhagavad Gita, and when you begin to appreciate Bhagavad
Gita we see what an inconceivable wealth of wisdom this Bhagavad Gita
contains. Everything is there in Bhagavad Gita. At the beginning of
Bhagavad Gita we are getting the understanding of the soul and our
identities being spiritual. Before coming across Bhagavad Gita or
before coming across Srila Prabhupada’s teachings how many of you
considered that you are a spirit soul? Okay. And what was your
understanding of spirit soul? Think about it very deeply. Did you
really have a clear understanding of spirit soul? Before coming across
Prabhupada’s Bhagavad Gita or Prabhupada’s teachings there was no
clear understanding of who the soul is. Actually, I mean, I don’t know
in America but I came across a very well educated, well set person
from the European background, Christian background. He is the
grandfather of one of our devotees and I was having a discussion with
him. He was a High Court judge and I had a difficult time to make him
understand that animals have souls. His belief was that animals don’t
have souls and here he is a High Court judge. It took me about twenty
minutes to make him understand what actually the soul is. So main
thing is that he didn’t have any understanding about what the soul is,
therefore, he just went along with the Christian concept: only human
beings have souls, animals don’t have souls.
So the reality is that wherever there is life, wherever there is
consciousness, we have to conclude that there is a soul. Trees and
plants, are they conscious? [Audience: yes] Therefore, they are
living. Therefore, there is a spirit soul. The trees are borne and the
trees will die at some point just as human beings. Animals are
conscious. You beat an animal it will cry. You attack an animal and it
will defend itself. So this is how we can see that wherever there is
consciousness we have to conclude that there is a spirit soul. Now the
nature of the spirit soul…Yes, we may have accepted the existence of
the spirit soul and the identity of the spirit soul, or the identity
being spiritual, but there is no clear understanding of what a spirit
soul is. Now let’s get a better understanding of the spirit soul. The
spirit soul is what makes this body alive.
Spirit soul is the source of consciousness. It is due to the presence
of spirit soul that the body is alive. The body goes through so many
wonderful changes the body performs so many wonderful activities. Like
every single organ of this body is such a complex mechanism… like the
kidney, a simple organ of this body. What does it do? It is filtering
the blood. The blood in the course of circulation is becoming impure,
contaminated and the kidney is purifying that. When it goes bad, then
we have to go for dialysis and a huge complex machine but in the body
it is naturally there without even us knowing about it. So this is the
result of the presence of the soul. The soul is in the body and so
many wonderful organs are functioning .The kidney, the liver, the
lungs, the heart and on top of that the blood circulation, the
respiratory system, nervous system, and the brain, like… simply due to
the presence of the soul and that is our real identity. We are spirit
soul. That is what we understand when we study the scriptures like
Bhagavad Gita. Bhagavad Gita gives us a very basic understanding.
First consideration is difference between the matter and spirit, the
body and soul, and we begin to recognize that our actual identity is
spiritual and that is immortal. The soul is immortal – we change the
body. The departure of the soul from one body is called death and the
acceptance of a new body by the soul is called birth. Birth is soul’s
acceptance of a new body and death is the soul’s departure from the
old body. And the period between, as long as the soul is in the body
we call it life.
Jai Sri Sri Pancatattava Ki Jai;
Sri Krsna Caitanya Prabhu Nityananda Sri Advaita Gadhara Srivasadi
Gaura Bhakta Vrinda
So that is what so wonderfully has been explained. And then it goes to
understanding Krishna. We understand the soul, we being spiritual, our
identity being spiritual, we being spirit soul. And then we get to
understand the difference between us and the supreme soul – Krishna.
That also Krishna has done very wonderfully in the 4th chapter. In
the second chapter Krishna has established the identity of spiritual
entity called the Spirit soul. In the 3rd chapter Krishna gives the
knowledge of Karma yoga – how to function. This arrangement from the
time of creation has been designed by the Supreme Personality of
Godhead and there are different arrangements. There are demigods,
there are living entities and the demigods are here to supply the
needs of the human beings and the human beings in return are supposed
to react towards the demigods in certain ways like paying them tax in
the form of sacrifices and so forth and then in the beginning of 4th
chapter Krishna told Arjuna that I gave this knowledge first to
Vivashvan – the Sun God
imam vivasvate yogam proktavn aham avyayam, vivasvan manave praha then
Sun God Vivasvan gave it to his son Manu manur iksvakave ‘bravit…then
Manu gave it to his son Ikvasku. evam parampara-praptam imam rajarsayo
viduh…in this way through a chain of disciplic succession of saintly
kings, this knowledge was flowing, but in course of time it has become
lost. sa kaleneha mahata yogo nastah parantapa. Then he says, sa
evayam maya te ‘dya yogah proktah puratanah…now that whole yoga that I
have spoken long time ago, I will give it to you, to re-establish this
wisdom. Then Arjuna had a natural question because we have to
understand the relationship between Arjuna and Krishna is that of
cousins. Arjuna’s mother was Krishna’a aunt and Krishna’s father was
Arjuna’s uncle. They were brother and sister. Vasudev and Kunti were
brother and sister. So that way they were relatives – cousins. And
they were of the same age. Therefore they had a very intimate
relationship. So Arjuna naturally asked him, look Krishna you are born
just the other day aparam? bhavato janma param janma param janma
vivasvatah?…Vivasvan was born so long ago param? janma vivasvatah?
katham etad vijnayam tvam dau proktavan iti. How can we understand you
spoke this wisdom to Vivasvan because Vivasvan was born so many
millions of years ago and you were born just the other day. How can I
understand that you have spoken? Then Krishna told him bah?ni me
vyat?t?ni janm?ni tava c?rjuna t?ny aham? veda sarv?n?i na tvam?
vettha parantapa. Many many times both you and I have taken birth. But
about those births, you do not remember anything whereas I remember
everything. t?ny aham? veda sarv?n?i. Sarvani means all – about all
those births, all those activities, of every single moment I remember
everything and then Krishna says that actually I am unborn, I don’t
need to take birth but still I take birth, not take birth, I appear by
the arrangement of my internal potency – yoga maya. ajo ‘pi sann
avyayam bhatanam isvaro ‘pi san prakritim svam adhisthaya sambhavamy
atma-mayaya…atma mayayaya, my internal potency, sambhavani, not borne,
sambhavami manifest by, and why Krishna comes that He explains – when
there is a decline of religious principles and increase of
irreligiosity, to establish the principle of dharma, principle of
religion He comes. So in this way Krishna establishes the difference
between us and Him. We should not think that Krishna is one of us, No,
Krishna is the origin of all of us, Krishna is the source of all of
us. So in this way in Upanishads example is given just like the sun
and innumerable rays are coming out of the sun. Now each ray of the
sun qualitatively is one with the sun but quantitatively they are
different. It is a tiny little ray whereas the sun is an inconceivable
source of all the rays. We are tiny, we are minute but Krishna is
absolute. Krishna is the absolute. But qualitatively we are same.
Krishna is sachidananda, Krishna is spiritual, we are spiritual.
Krishna is sac-cid-ananda. Krishna is eternal, full of knowledge, full
of bliss. We are also eternal, full of bliss. But those qualities, the
spiritual qualities of Krishna will be there in us only when we are
connected with Him. When we become submissive to Krishna we become
endowed with those qualities. But when we become separated from
Krishna we lose those qualities. An example has been given. Like, a
spark is also fire. A spark is fire, isn’t it? But the spark is a tiny
part, a tiny speck of fire. When the spark comes out of the fire then
what happens? Yeah, it loses its fiery qualities. It’s extinguished
and it falls on a heap of ash just next to the fire. And it becomes
ash, losing its fiery qualities. Our condition is somewhat like that.
We are spiritual but being separated from Krishna we lost our
spiritual qualities and falling into matter we are now identifying
ourselves with matter. We are thinking we are this body. The speck of
fire that was a spark now it became ash, but it has the ability to be
ignited. But for that it has to go back to the fire. Similarly when we
reestablish our relationship with Krishna we resume our spiritual
qualities. And Krishna consciousness means to establish our
relationship with Krishna again. Now we are identifying ourselves with
matter and as a result of that we are thinking we are the body and we
are functioning according to the moves of the body, according the
demands of the body and according to the cravings of the body. But
when we reestablish our relationship with Krishna then we will regain
our spiritual qualities again. Just as you take the speck of
inflammable particle that used to be a spark at one time back to fire,
what happens? Immediately it becomes fire. So that is what Krishna
consciousness is.

And how to reestablish our lost relationship with Krishna? By
developing our loving relationship with Him. Love is the criteria.
Love is the force. Love is the factor that unites us with Krishna and
that love is called bhakti or devotional service. Devotional service,
love, real love is expressed through service, through action. So if we
love Krishna we have to express that love, because we are active
elements. We all are active individuals. We have to act. So when we
act in order to express our love for Krishna then we become
reconnected, reunited with Him. So that is the simple teaching of
Bhagavad Gita and all the Vedic scriptures.
Thank you all very much! Hare Krishna! [applause]
Thank you. Does anybody have any question or comment? Yes?

Question: Maharaja, can you please explain the difference between Yoga
maya, Atma maya and Daivi maya?
BCS: Yes, actually Daivi maya,Yoga Maya and Atma maya is the same.
Maya means energy of the Lord. And there are two types of energies in
that respect: external energy which is called Maha maya and internal
energy of the Lord which is called Yoga maya or Atma maya or Daivi
maya. Daivi hy esa guna-mayi [Bg 7.14]. So here it is Daivi because
although indicating Maha maya but it is implying that this maya is
Mine, therefore it is Daivi maya. Daivi means divine. But maya
actually is a potency of the Lord it also means the illusory effect of
the Lord’s energy. In both the natures, in material and spiritual, the
Lord’s energy is bewildering us. Like, in the material nature it is
bewildering us and taking us away from Krishna, and imprisoning us
into the material nature. Whereas in the spiritual nature Yoga maya is
engaging us in Krishna’s service making the arrangements. That’s also
a kind of illusion. Especially Yoga maya is in Vrindavana. In
Vrindavana Yoga maya causes the living entities or devotees or
residents of Vrindavana to forget that Krishna is the Supreme
Personality of Godhead. But here also we can consider that this maya
is of two types. Maya means illusion. Illusion means not to recognize
an object as it is. That’s what illusion is. So in the material nature
our illusion or forgetfulness is due to our ignorance. But in the
spiritual nature the forgetfulness of Krishna as the Supreme
Personality of Godhead is Yogamaya’s arrangement, or the effect of
Yogamaya which is due to love. Forgetfulness due to love. One is,
sometimes we forget due to our ignorance and sometimes we forget due
to love. For example, the son became the state president. It’s not
that the mother doesn’t know that her son is the state president but
because of her love for him she doesn’t care that he is the state
president. It is not important that he is the state president. If he
comes home late she chastises him, “What were you doing so late?!” So
this is the forgetfulness due to love.
There were some questions? Yes?

Question: You were explaining that this is Bhagavad Gita As It Is, or
this way Krishna spoke the subject, right? And Vyasadeva is the one
who compiled it [unclear]. So what Krishna said and what Arjuna
understood did Vyasadeva explain that?
BCS: Very good. You see, what Vyasadeva did, he just…these
personalities like Vyasadeva they have an inconceivable memory. Like,
you can consider a tape recorder. Their memory is like a first class
tape recorder. Everything is recorded here. And they could repeat it
anytime. So, after Krishna’s pastimes Vyasadeva got Ganesha to write.
So Vyasadeva was just narrating what was happening and he wrote.
Vyasadeva didn’t give any commentary, but the understanding comes from
a qualified teacher. Vyasadeva wrote the book who is like a publisher.
He printed the book and marketed the book. But you, just by buying the
book from a bookshop cannot master the subject. So what’s your
profession? [Audience member: engineer] You are an engineer. To become
an engineer what you have to do? You go to an engineering college, you
have to study the books according to the syllabus and then under the
guidance of a qualified teacher. So it is a qualified teacher who
simplifies the knowledge from the book. So that is the business of a
teacher. So here, Prabhupada, as a perfect teacher he explained the
actual meaning of Bhagavad Gita the way Krishna spoke and the way
Arjuna understood. I will tell you one thing. As I was telling about
reading Bhagavad Gita, I was reading Bhagavad Gita and actually one
inconceivable (?) thing I would kind of feel at that time, when I was
reading second chapter I thought second chapter is THE Bhagavad Gita.
Then I went to the first chapter I said, “Well, this is IT!

Here is Prabhupada as a perfect teacher, he is explaining the actual
meaning of Bhagavad Gita the way Krsna spoke and the way Arjuna
understood. That’s way you will see, like why I will tell you one
thing… as I was telling you about reading Bhagavad Gita. I was reading
Bhagavad Gita and actually one confusing thing that I used to kind of
feel at one time. When I as reading 2nd chapter, I felt 2nd chapter is
the Bhagavad Gita then I went to the 3rd chapter, I felt this is it
and then when I went to the 4th chapter I felt this is it.

But Srila Prabhupada when he gave Bhagavad Gita, he gave the last
instruction of Krishna in Bhagavad Gita as the first instruction.
Recognize that Krishna is the Supreme Personality of Godhead and
surrender unto Him. Then only you will be able to understand Bhagavad
Gita not otherwise. Now a qualified teacher or bonafide teacher like
Prahupada only teaches like that. Because he has the total
understanding that’s why he brings the last thing as the first for our
clarity. Right.

Yes you have a question. Yes

Question you have spoken about knowledge and devotion. . In
order to advance in knowledge

Gurumaharaj: Very good point. Very good point. You see, material
nature and spiritual nature function in different ways. In material
nature you first know, you first learn and then you have it. Whereas
in the spiritual world, you just become situated there and it
automatically comes, right? For example, like in the material nature
you have to perceive and then you have to conceive. Right. You see
things, you know about it and then you retain it, in your mind in your
intelligence in your brain. Whereas in spiritual nature you just
practice devotional service and the knowledge automatically comes to
your heart. Are you familiar with the expression – Divya Gyan Hrdya
Prakasito…Do you come to Gurupuja in the temple, Prabhupada guru puja?
Do you sing that song? Sri Guru Carana Padama… Do you know the line

Divya Gyan Hrdya Prakasito : one line from that song is the
transcendental knowledge is revealed in the heart. It is not retained
here it is revealed in the heart. It also has been analyzed in this
way that bhakti devi is the mother. Bhakti is the mother, and she has
two sons, those two sons are gyana and vairagya – Knowledge and
renunciation. So wherever the mother goes, the son will follow. So
wherever there is practice of bhakti there will be knowledge
–transcendental knowledge and automatically natural detachment. It
will automatically come. Right. Thank you. Hare Krishna

Yes.

Gurumaharaj: Very good point. That reminds me, recently, we were in
Pennsylvania (at) a retreat, and there, one devotee presented a skit –
kind of a drama, dramatically. The drama was about a conversation
between twins in the womb of the mother. So the way he portrayed it,
one girl was … two actors were sitting on two chairs crouched like
they were in the womb and a girl was standing behind them with a piece
of cloth which was covering them, and then she removed the thing
partly showing that what’s going on. So one of the embryos is sleeping
and the other one wakes him up. So he wakes up very agitated – let me
sleep, I slept only for 20 hours today and then he goes back to sleep
again. Then the other boy wakes him up again and he says look I have
something very important to say. He says I heard that there is life
after birth (GM laughs). And he says, and in that world there is
light. So the other says, how it is possible, how can there be light.
How can there be life after birth. This everything, just don’t think
beyond this. This is everything and try to enjoy as much as possible
(audience laughter). And then he continued, you know there we can eat
with our mouth and we can walk with our feet. So he was speaking like
that and the other boy, he was completely denied it – how is it
possible? Is there anyway we can eat except the umbilical cord. And he
said no really it can be …and so then in this way you know like it
just goes on. So I thought it was brilliant. Now when we look at our
situation form that context , don’t we see that our situation is like
that. We are living in a world, …O then it goes into, another very
important thing. He says do you know, we have a mother? He says how is
it possible, have you ever seen her? (Audience laughter). He says I
did not see her but I can feel her. Don’t you realize, don’t you feel
that it is because of her that we are existing and then he says, Oh
common there is no mother. He says, but we can see, she is all around
us. Although we do not see her, but she is all around us and it is
because of her that we are getting everything that we need. She is
taking care of us in all respects. And … anyway so I thought of
sharing. Like you know, I mean, It is so foolish actually, its so
stupid to think that this world is everything and our existing here is
everything. There is nothing beyond it. But for that to receive those
informations we need a bonafide teacher. We need Vaisnav teachings.
Spiritual master means (unclear ) who himself has the knowledge and
who can impart the knowledge to others. So Prabhupada has created so
many bonafide spiritual masters all over the world who are
distributing this knowledge and as a result of that the world will
benefit.

Ok. Thank you very much. All glories to Srila Prabhupada.

Views: 508

Comment

Hare Krishna! You need to be a member of ISKCON Desire Tree - Devotee Network to add comments!

Join ISKCON Desire Tree - Devotee Network

Receive Daily Nectar

Online Statistics

Addon Services

For more details:
Click here 


Back to Godhead Magazine !

For more details:
English | Hindi

© 2019   Created by ISKCON desire tree network.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service