- Me
i am discussing with my friends as they are non hindus like muslims and christians and they posed me so many questions, hope that i will get answers so that i can go back to them
can i ask?
- Me
the first question is why the god created the souls? if he is full and everything what the need for creating this world and that to living beings, even he created the animals why he created the man with mind and brain i.e full of wants and greed, lust and etc
the second question is why he introduced the souls with wants
and greed
if he is the creater of these wants why he is punshing the souls in the name of karma and prarabhdha
Me
the third question why the soul cannot break the karmic bond on its own as the soul is god's same thing, why the soul always immeresed in these worldly matters even he doesnot want on his own and again failure causes the rebirth and cycle forever
the fouth question is why lord is siliently enjoyig when the soul is suffering with various diseases and he cannot blamed for it as the karma of the soul, if the karma is assigned by him then why the soul is getting punishment more
the fifith question: even he created the same and entire thing created by him why he created the unequal and unfair to some as changelled persons and diseased person and his fate is ill and some one fate is well even both did the same work and same job at same time
the sixth question
why the vedic knowledge only confined to india
the seventh question : if rama and krishna are gods why they are limited to inida but not rest of the world, why the other parts of world 100% lost the faith on them even in india also by the culture degradtion why it is moving down
the eighth question if india is great country the land of lords why there is still only land lords but not lord of the land for the world
if he is god why he cannot influence the rest of the world by his actions
how the world forgets him even if he is a god
and atleast some remains like stones or antiques even confiend to india , if he is god then why india only always as his birth place
the ninth question: why the people of india cannot read all the vedas and no one knows all that in the book then how we can say that is more sacred than the rest of the world, even any thing u say, then it will be in vedas why till now it is un explored? and un known to man kind
hope that our team will answer these questions so that i can go back and say to them with full devotion on lord krishna and hindusim
ok hare krishna
- Me
You need to be a member of ISKCON Desire Tree | IDT to add comments!
Comments
i will try my level best to answer those questions you had mentioned prabhuji with the knowledge and mercy from my sikshaguru that is from disciple session of gaudiya sampradhaya.
ans for 1st question:we can understand lord in 3 ways
1.paramathma thathva(lord is supersoul,and this thathva proves lords presence everywhere in the hole creation)
2.nirakara thahva(this explains lords power and his superiority over material nature he is trancedental )
3.sakara thathva(indicating his sathchith ananda rupa)
for further details u can go through book of HDGprabhu padh "science of self realization" espacia;;y the letters
lord gave every soul(individual) LITTILE independence. and he will not interfere in it.
he is not expecting robotic love from us .if u programe robot it will work as u mentioned in programe(software) .but that programmed love is not satisfactory. feelings love this things happen only in independence that we should understand.
and fortunate one and good souls remain in vaikunta &who miss use there independence fall to this materisl world.and different animal life has purpose . for example a cheif minister should do job of cheif minister .ok but if he trys to do watch man job .soon the authorities dismiss him and he can happily do that job. in the same way some people like to sleep (thamasika happiness) then krishna mercy fully says ho! u r intrested in sleeping but this human body is not fit for that better u take the body of bear(that sleeps for 6 months . like this he is showing mercy. and used word punishing .no it is not punishing it is training and teaching . by karma system he is trying to make us realize our constitutional position.
soul is part and parcel of krishna but it is anu(water drop of ocean) where as lord is paramanu(ocean) he is equal with qualities but not quantity. so he is imperfect without lord.screw has value when it is withe machine ,if not it has no value.so our relation with krishna (svarupa siddhi)is based on love, surrenderence. what ever we see connected to krishna is spritual .whatever we see individually it is material then u used why cant individual soul can attain spritual without krishna helpas it is part fo god himself .but my question is what is spritual if there is no krishna?
as i explined earlier krishna dont have any interference with karma . karma is not made by him. but ourselves. and what he says to come out of karma.and it is not punishment it is training for purity. example gold is shaped after heating it and hiting with hammer but it is all for final good shape.
he said it this world is dhukalayam ashasvatham. this world is full of misiries so we should get of it. unequality is due to their past actions .a murderer is supposed to be in jail. u cant leave him if u put him jail then his conciousness and way of thinking will change oh i should not do this.though he tempted in future he will slowly change due proper treatment by government.
if u go to a new city and u want to stay for night will u go to your loving friends are strangers house? u will go for loving friends house . in the same way in india people know who is god and his name and qualities and even more they loe(bhakthi) him so he appears in india .it is kali last yuga among 4.so it happens when u take dirty water if u purify in four stages at last satge u will finally get so much concentrated waste .so we are most mischeivies children of lord.
ur 8th question answer is that i already said lord does not little interfeierence of living entities
in kali yuga dharma is just chanting hare krishna mahamantra. go through prabhu padha boks .
prabhu my personal request to u is u meet a local iskcon authorized devotee and have constant assocition with him only that will be the perfect way. for ur perfection in spritual life hare krishna thank u for this oppurtunity